ProPlanet 8" and 10" scopes

Started by drachal, 06/11/2008 09:59PM
Posted 06/11/2008 09:59PM Opening Post
I noticed in the latest issue of Astronomy Technology Today that Discovery is coming out with a couple of truss tube reflectors, specifically designed to enhance planetary observing, at very reasonable prices.

The 8"F9 is $1000.00 and the 10" F7.2 is $1300.00. They have some very nice features according to the article.

Darian R.
Posted 06/11/2008 10:53PM #1
Wow, that 10 inch scope sounds very cool. Long focus Newtonians are a rare breed these days. I wonder how eye the eyepiece is at zenith? i.e. do you need a ladder.

I would suspect that it is borderline and depends on the observers height. Personally I would rather be looking through a 12.5 inch F/6 than a 10 inch F/7.2 though both have very similar focal lengths and are about equal manageable... In my experience, aperture buys more than focal ratio, particular if one is already at F/6.

Jon

Jon
Posted 06/12/2008 01:35PM #2
Scott, I sent you a PM regarding this.

Darian R.
Posted 06/12/2008 01:49PM #3
I guess these will have a similar appearance and build quality to the other Discovery truss tube Dobs.

SPECS: The mirrors have enhanced coatings. Minimal secondary on curved spider. 2 speed, low profile Crayford focuser. Telrad. shroud.

Darian R.
Posted 06/12/2008 02:34PM | Edited 06/12/2008 03:04PM #4
Hi Darian,

I noticed the brief description as well and have to say I am curious about the scopes. While I agree with Jon about aperture ruling, there are many ways to optimize a Newtonian for planetary viewing not the least of which is reducing the secondary size. Unfortunately, that normally means longer focal lengths. At the moment, I have two excellent 8" Scopes, an old Cave 8" F/8 and a Uti 8" F/6. The Cave has a 1.3" secondary (16% CO) and the Uti 1.83" (22% CO). Side by side on fine planetary detail the Cave has a slight edge which I chock up to the smaller CO as both have excellent mirrors. Having said that, the best visual view I have ever had of Mars in a reflecting telescope was through a 10" F/5 Portaball. In my experience, the Moon and planet come alive in 10" and larger scopes. A very experienced observer I know says that 12.5" is the "sweet spot" in planetary scopes and I have to agree: the 12.5" Portaball is stunning on planets and the Moon.
Posted 06/28/2008 08:21PM | Edited 06/28/2008 11:08PM #5
I've owned my share of long focus Newtonians in my decades long quest for Newtonian planetary perfection wink As with all things, there is no free lunch. Observing from a ladder or step stool is tolerable for a time but for me grows old. I much prefer sit down observing.

If I could find a lens maker that wouldn't charge "through the roof" in the fabrication of a 40mm cemented doublet I would have a nice solution for a planetary Newtonian.

Though the idea is not new, a permanently mounted telenegative amplifier (barlow) would solve a lot of issues concerning constructing a planetary Newtonian.

1. A long focal ratio scope could be achieved with a relatively short tube.
2. The obstruction could be easily kept to 20% while fully illuminating a 1/4 degree FOV.
3. Common glasses in the barlow/corrector would keep the cost of glass low.
4. Performance of the barlow/corrector would have a diffraction limited field of 23 arc minutes (almost 1/2 degree).
5. Visual high performance could be achieved with "standard" eyepieces.
6. The resulting large image scale would be good for planetary CCD photography.

I produced such an instrument many years ago. It performed quite well but I would like to take it a step higher by using a lens designed specifically for the optic concerned thereby attaining even better on and off axis performance. Here is a 12 inch F/14 Newtonian using a standard F/5 primary. Any lens makers out there?

Keith

Attached Image:

klawson's attachment for post 123298

Scopejunkie


40 year old restored C14 with recirculating cooling w/Skywatcher DOB GOTO Conversion (CPC14)

Synscan DOB mounted Sky-Watcher Evostar 150mm/1200mm ED Refractor

"Rescued" Craig's List Orion 120mm/1000mm Refractor


USAF Vet