Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Secondary Mirror Question

Started by [email protected], 09/12/2008 02:39AM
Posted 09/12/2008 02:39AM | Edited 09/12/2008 02:42AM Opening Post
I've been looking at the data of my secondary (3.1") for my 16" f/4.52 dob with NEWT. I tend to go a bit small on my secondary, as I did on my old 12.5" f/6 with a 1.83" in order to achieve a bit higher contrast with the loss of some edge brightness. As I'm looking at this, I'm wondering if I can reduce my secondary to a 2.6"?

Here is the data plugged in with a 3.1"


The same with a 2.6" secondary


With the 3.1, it says that I have vignetting of focuser at 75% ray, whereas the 2.6 does not. However, the reverse is true for the "diagonal too small to admit 100% ray" where the 2.6 says no and the 3.1 says yes.

Opinions? And for those who might say, yes, smaller secondary, then which company would you recommend; Galaxy, Protostar, Pegasus, University?

Thanks,

Guy

16" f/4.52 ATM Truss Dob, Discovery Mirror
Denk II w/nags junkie

Posted 09/12/2008 12:38PM #1
Guy:

If you look at the numbers for the 2.6 inch inch secondary you will see that the fully illuminated field of view is -0.1928 degrees. What the minus sign means is that the secondary is too small to fully illuminate the very center of the field of view, ie, you will not be operating at full aperture even at the center.



In otherwords... the 2.6 inch is definitely too small, your scope will not operate as a 16 inch but rather something smaller, maybe you will only see 15 inches or maybe only 14 inches of the mirror...

The 3.1 inch provides a 19.4% CO, that ought to be plenty small...

Jon
Posted 09/13/2008 04:42AM #2
Guy,
For me, the critical thing is the width of the 75% illuminated field. Anything less than 75% bothers me, and there are cases where even 75% bothers me, but it's liveable. With the 3.1" mirror, the 75% illuminated field is exactly the diameter of the maximum field stop in a 2" eyepiece. So, I'd definitely go with the 3.1", if I wanted to use such an eyepiece. That's already cutting it close. This scope is going to be seeing limited anyhow, it's so big, so don't worry about it. 3.5" would give visually perfect widest field views.
Ron
Posted 09/13/2008 02:50PM #3
One other thing to consider - are you planning to use a paracorr? Don't forget that the paracorr barrell sticks about 3" into the focuser. If you use a super-low-profle focuser to minimize your secondary obstruction, then you may end up with the barrel of the paracorr sticking into the light path, which will act just like the secondary, only square (so it will produce spikes rather than round diffraction).

On my 14.7" f4.4, I could have just managed a 2.6" secondary by letting the paracorr stick about 1" into the light path. But that adds 2 quare inches of obstruction, which is about the same total as a 3.1" secondary, and the 3.1" will give much better illumination. If there was a commercial source for a 2.8", that would have been perfect, but there isn't. So I went with a 3.1" for the scope. I would recommend the same for your 16".

Jarad