I've been looking at the data of my secondary (3.1") for my 16" f/4.52 dob with NEWT. I tend to go a bit small on my secondary, as I did on my old 12.5" f/6 with a 1.83" in order to achieve a bit higher contrast with the loss of some edge brightness. As I'm looking at this, I'm wondering if I can reduce my secondary to a 2.6"?
Here is the data plugged in with a 3.1"

The same with a 2.6" secondary

With the 3.1, it says that I have vignetting of focuser at 75% ray, whereas the 2.6 does not. However, the reverse is true for the "diagonal too small to admit 100% ray" where the 2.6 says no and the 3.1 says yes.
Opinions? And for those who might say, yes, smaller secondary, then which company would you recommend; Galaxy, Protostar, Pegasus, University?
Thanks,
Guy
Here is the data plugged in with a 3.1"

The same with a 2.6" secondary

With the 3.1, it says that I have vignetting of focuser at 75% ray, whereas the 2.6 does not. However, the reverse is true for the "diagonal too small to admit 100% ray" where the 2.6 says no and the 3.1 says yes.
Opinions? And for those who might say, yes, smaller secondary, then which company would you recommend; Galaxy, Protostar, Pegasus, University?
Thanks,
Guy
16" f/4.52 ATM Truss Dob, Discovery Mirror
Denk II w/nags junkie