Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Secondary size question

Started by Buck8one2, 05/23/2007 11:08PM
Posted 05/23/2007 11:08PM | Edited 05/23/2007 11:08PM Opening Post
OK, nothing special to do snd I start crunching numbers concerning secondaries and I find a problem. At present I have an 11" at 60.2" focal length, and a 1.83" Astrosystems secondary. Because of the way the holder is made it wraps around the mirror so the effective obstruction is 1 7/8" or 1.875" which is 17% obstruction very good. However, if you figure the clear portion because of the wrap you loose a bit more than 1/16" per edge or .190" total all the way around which leaves the effective clear mirror of 1.685" which the programs say is too small and I do not get full illumination. Now the next size up is 2.14 with the same type holder comes out to about 2.18" obstruction or 20% still not bad and the clear usable mirror is 1.99" which is plenty big enough (program says appox. 1.80 needed for full illumination. So here is my question. Is it worth giving up the 3% more obstruction to get the full illumination?
Thanks
Buck
Posted 05/23/2007 11:53PM #1
How large an area are you fully illuminating at the focal
plane?
Posted 05/24/2007 05:08AM #2

Buck,
You need full illumination over the field stop of a high-powered eyepiece, say 5mm, so you'll get full resolution where it counts. It sound like you're on top of that. But another concern is that at your lowest power, where the field stop may be 46mm in diameter, you need to have at least 70% illumination at the edge, or the image will appear dim near the edge of the field of view. Most people say 70% is a good minimum, and I agree, having tried less.
Ron