Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

10% obstruction (1% area)

Started by BoyntonStu, 03/30/2006 04:04PM
Posted 03/30/2006 04:04PM Opening Post
I have been playing around with Newt and I have calculated a 4.5" mirror with a 0.5" diagonal that is doable with no loss or vignetting. A sled focuser with the eypiece barrel bottom just inside would push the focal plane way up the tube.

How would the contrast be for a 10% obstruction?

Are there any reflectors with very small diagonals out there?


Stu
Posted 03/31/2006 06:08AM | Edited 03/31/2006 06:21AM #1
[COLOR="Blue"]
Stu Lieberman said:

I have been playing around with Newt and I have calculated a 4.5" mirror with a 0.5" diagonal that is doable with no loss or vignetting. A sled focuser with the eypiece barrel bottom just inside would push the focal plane way up the tube.

How would the contrast be for a 10% obstruction?

Are there any reflectors with very small diagonals out there?

Stu
[/COLOR]
Hi Stu,

I made a 10" scope with a 12% obstruction, and no spider at all, but technically my secondary is 100% wink

I have some pictures on my web site:

www.planetatm.com

Stars focus down to very small points, and no spider diffraction on bright objects either smile

if 10% gives you a 1/8-1/4" illuminated field, then you should have a fine view.




Attached Image:

David Simons's attachment for post 102296

David Simons
Posted 03/31/2006 01:16PM #2
I have been playing around with Newt and I have calculated a 4.5" mirror with a 0.5" diagonal that is doable with no loss or vignetting. A sled focuser with the eypiece barrel bottom just inside would push the focal plane way up the tube.
-----

Some random thoughts:

1. There has to be a drop off in the illuminated field of view at some point, what is the fully illuminated field of view you have calculated?

2. What parameters did you use? What sort of focuser height did you use? The focuser height, tube diameter and wall thickness determine the location of the focal plane.

Since many eyepieces have a focal plane quite aways inside the barrel, it is difficult to keep the barrel from intruding into the light path.

Using what would seem to me to be minimums of a 5 inch tube with a 0.1 inch wall and a 1 inch focuser with no in focus, I get a fully illuminated FOV of less than a 0.1 degree.

Personally I think you would not see the loss of contrast between a 0.75 inch diagonal and a 0.5 and barely see the loss between a 1 inch and a 0.5 inch. In a big scope where the images are bright and things are more apparent, it is not that big a deal. Looking through smaller Newtonians, I don't normally see much effect of the CO. My 6 inch F8 provides nice contrasty images with a 22% CO.

Jon
Posted 03/31/2006 02:03PM #3
Stu
For a given scope contrast is a function of a variety of factors. Suffice to say, however, that a 10% (by diameter) central obstruction will introduce no visible loss of contrast. One issue, however, that you should be aware of:
In a planetary optimized scope, where ever last bit of diagonal is being used, be sure the diagonal has a good edge. If not all efforts towards such optimization are wasted.
Joe

16" F5 "Front Collimating" mirror cell