Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

16" plate glass mirror

Started by fguihen, 11/03/2008 10:51AM
Posted 11/03/2008 10:51AM | Edited 11/03/2008 04:27PM Opening Post
im currently in the design phase of a 16" obsession style dob.
While trying to source optics, an astronomer who lives close by to me offered me a brand new 16" , 1" thick plate glass primary for 1000 euros.

this is a great price for a 16" mirror ( in europe), however when i do some reasearch, some opical suppliers dont recommend plate glass above 12 inches. even the company where he purchased the mirror from doesnt recommend them above 12", but they still sell them. The point here is not to ask if the guy is trustworthy, i know him and know he is.

my question is why would a company sell a 16" plate glass mirror but not recommend it?

Considering 1000 euro is about as far as my budget will stretch, and il only get a 12-14" primary in low expension glass, is there any reason to seriously avoid a 16" plate glass mirror?
Posted 11/03/2008 05:19PM | Edited 11/03/2008 05:20PM #1
Hi,
There are many problems with a 1" thick 16" mirror.

First, the mirror cell will have to be very precise and have a lot of support points as the thin mirror will be very easy to distort.

Then, the plate glass will tend to change shape slightly with temperature effecting the figure due to internal stress as it is not that well made or annealed.

Plus, during grinding and figuring the 16" thin mirror is difficult to work with and will tend to change as it cools, making the final figuring very tough.

So, though not impossible to make, it would likely not be a great mirror. With many possible problems to mount, cool and perhaps never produce a great image.

However, this does not make it impossible for it to be done, just more difficult.

Better to get a 1.25 to 1.5" thick Pyrex mirror, it would be a better investment in my opinion.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager