I have an old 4" (4.25" actually) F15 Jaegers lens. I've heard these can make very good planetary scopes. I don't have the time or skill to build a nice OTA. So I've been in touch a builder who will put together a complete OTA for about $900. I'm excited about the process, but are these lenses good enough to warrant the effort? Is the old long tube achromat really dead?
4" F15 Refractor Should I?
Started by Bill in Ballard, 04/02/2004 02:51AM
Posted 04/02/2004 02:51AM
Opening Post
Posted 04/02/2004 07:59AM
#1
Bill,
The price seems a bit high, but not much. If the objective is as nice as they are reputed to be, you should get a lot of satisfaction from it.
I have a 4" f 15 Vixen Research Grade achromat OTA on a GM-8, and get much satisfaction from it. It's an excellent planetary scope, comparing very well with larger SCT's.
I typically take several scopes out to local viewing sites, but wind up doing more viewing with the 4" than the others because of the simplicity of setup and quality of views.
James Adams
The price seems a bit high, but not much. If the objective is as nice as they are reputed to be, you should get a lot of satisfaction from it.
I have a 4" f 15 Vixen Research Grade achromat OTA on a GM-8, and get much satisfaction from it. It's an excellent planetary scope, comparing very well with larger SCT's.
I typically take several scopes out to local viewing sites, but wind up doing more viewing with the 4" than the others because of the simplicity of setup and quality of views.
James Adams
Posted 04/02/2004 03:47PM
#3
Bill,
If possible, have someone check the lens before spending a lot of money to mount it. Like many other companies, the quality of the Jaegers lenses varied. The figure on yours could be fine, but there is no quarantee.
You will obviously have the secondary color appropriate to a 4" f/15 achromat. I used a 4" f/15 Clark for two years, and, while the color was there, I did not find it too objectionable, and the lens provided fine lunar and planetary views.
Clear skies, Alan
If possible, have someone check the lens before spending a lot of money to mount it. Like many other companies, the quality of the Jaegers lenses varied. The figure on yours could be fine, but there is no quarantee.
You will obviously have the secondary color appropriate to a 4" f/15 achromat. I used a 4" f/15 Clark for two years, and, while the color was there, I did not find it too objectionable, and the lens provided fine lunar and planetary views.
Clear skies, Alan
Posted 04/02/2004 05:14PM
#4
A 2x4, a quick-n-dirty lens cell at one end and an eyepiece at the other should let you test the quality of the lens.
$900 seems a lot of money to sink into an old achromat, more than twice as much as I saw a 4" Jaegers go for elsewhere. A sheet of plywood, some glue, screws and a homebuilt or expensive focuser, much less money...
$900 seems a lot of money to sink into an old achromat, more than twice as much as I saw a 4" Jaegers go for elsewhere. A sheet of plywood, some glue, screws and a homebuilt or expensive focuser, much less money...
Posted 04/03/2004 03:45AM
#5
I'm a big fan of long-tube refractors and have a bunch
of them. Genericly speaking, here is no reason why it
cannot be a superb instrument. But I agree it would
be prudent to evaluate the lens before building a
scope around it. There is also alot which can be
done via re-spacing the elements, just in case yours
tests sub-par.
of them. Genericly speaking, here is no reason why it
cannot be a superb instrument. But I agree it would
be prudent to evaluate the lens before building a
scope around it. There is also alot which can be
done via re-spacing the elements, just in case yours
tests sub-par.
Posted 04/03/2004 04:37AM
#6
I have a 4 1/4" Jaegers and am very impressed with it's performance. It's a good planetary scope and absolutely stunning in the moon. With the moon, the contrast is so good it's like being there. I have a 5" semi-apo and a Questar 7 which I used for comparison. It's definitely worth using, but $900 is way too much for a tube in my opinion.
You need some 4" thin wall aluminum tubing, a focuser, an adapter plate for the focuser and a couple baffles. Add a Telrad finder and a pair of Orion tube rings and you are there. If you are short on time for scope building, watch for a Jaegers 4 1/4" on Astromart and buy it. You can pick one up for a lot less that $900. You could sell your lens to someone else who has the time to make a tube.
I'm in San Diego. If you would like to send me the lens, I'd be happy to use my OTA to compare your lens to the one I have.
You need some 4" thin wall aluminum tubing, a focuser, an adapter plate for the focuser and a couple baffles. Add a Telrad finder and a pair of Orion tube rings and you are there. If you are short on time for scope building, watch for a Jaegers 4 1/4" on Astromart and buy it. You can pick one up for a lot less that $900. You could sell your lens to someone else who has the time to make a tube.
I'm in San Diego. If you would like to send me the lens, I'd be happy to use my OTA to compare your lens to the one I have.
There are only 10 kinds of people who understand binary - those that do and those that don't
Funding Member