Adjusting for Focal Length

Started by starbucket, 03/01/2004 08:47AM
Posted 03/01/2004 08:47AM Opening Post
First let me say hello to all. I have been working on a restoration for the past 3 months. This is a 8" F/8 Cave Astrola Newtonian. Finnally got to test this baby out last night, short test, bummer. Seems the focuser has came up a little short for F.L. This is odd because I used all the orginal parts mirrors, mirror cell, tube, and focuser. Unless it was working at the extreme far edge from the start. The mirror has F.L. 63 11/16" wrote on it. I have run the figures on the newt program and it comes up with a F.L. of 64" with the focuser thats on it now its max is 64 1/4 ". Have a few lower F.L. EPs that will come in focus at max or a little less, but most EPs have to be pulled out up to 3/4" to get focus.
My question is am I overlooking something? and if not what is the easiest fix. Change the focuser or recess the primary 1.5" to aquire the needed F.L. Your sugestions are very welcomed.
Thanks Kent
Posted 03/01/2004 11:19AM #1
It must've been off/wrong to begin with, but how would you know since it was a commercial scope?

See if the mirror cell can be modified to drop the mirror 1/2" or better. My second choice would be to move the entire mirror cell. I wouldn't personally move the focuser--too ugly.

I never trust Newt.exe or even the FL written written on the mirror back--it's too easy to make a mistake and you only have about .25" of room for error with low profile focusers that have ~1.25" of travel if you want the majority of eyepieces out there to work. So I always leave the tube a couple inches longer than I think it needs to be and test for where the actual focal plane lies using the actual mirror in the actual tube (a lot of "actual" going on there... ;^). Then, after I know for certain, I mount the cell in place.

You ought to be able to get 3/4" without having to play with the focuser, but if you can't, then you might also consider making a focuser mounting block to raise it a little, in conjunction with one of the other methods described. However, I like to optimize the secondary size as much as possible and raising the focuser works against that. Add to that, those old scopes already had tall focusers, so you probably don't want to make it any taller.

Good luck.

P.S. I had the same problem once after getting a new mirror to put in an old tube--I had no back end left to drop the mirror cell and I refused to move the focuser and make a new hole, so I made extension blocks and hung the cell out of the back of the tube, as shown below.





Attached Image:

P. Lee Stock's attachment for post 76991
Posted 03/01/2004 06:08PM #2
How about a simple block under the focuser raising it by 1/2-3/4"?
I would try to lower the primary first, but if it won't go, then try raising the focuser.
Are you sure the focuser is the original and not a shorter one?
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 03/02/2004 06:41PM #3
Thank you Lee, Mark, and Floyd for your insights and possible solutions on this problem. Lee you have a dynamite setup on the scope pictured. Looks like a piece of art and I bet its performance equals its looks smile.
Double checked everything, focuser squared ( 2 1/4" tall), secondary centered and squared, mirror down in cell mount as close as possible ( tightened collimation screws all the down then backed off for collimation, it is spring loaded didn't want to shorten springs) still no go. The tube gave me just enough room to move the mirror cell back 7/8" results awesome! I Can See! LOL. All my EPs came to focus. Just wish the seeing was better for test last night. Will have to wait now for a good night. Still have work to finnish this project but at least now I know the optics are working. Thanks guys, will post specifics on this project when it's complete. Which I hope is not to far off.
Kent