A lot has been written about baffling Newtonian reflectors, but I’m wondering if it is overkill in most cases. The attached picture is a scale CAD drawing I made of my 13.1-inch f/4.5. The tube has an ID of 16”. The blue arc at the left represents the front surface of the primary mirror, radius of curvature 117 inches. The short blue line at the right is the focal disk 58.5 inches from the primary, which I arbitrarily set to 1 inch diameter. The black lines represent light rays that just hit the outer edge of the focal disk. The yellow lines are normals to the mirror’s surface, about which these focal plane edge-grazing rays are reflected.
As you can see from the diagram, there are no light rays that can reflect off the inside of the tube (red lines), strike the primary mirror, and end up in the focal disk. If they do reflect off the inside of the tube, then they’ll miss the focal disk. In other words, no part of the inside of the tube is visible from the focal plane. All such rays would have to reflect twice off the inside of the tube, which is no biggie. Simple flat black paint would be fine – even at 5% reflectance, two reflections would result in only .0025% of the light reaching the focal disk.
Am I looking at this correctly? If I am, then putting annular baffles inside the tube do nothing. But, I think it would be advantageous to add a baffle at the open end of the tube to prevent seeing the sky itself.
FWIW, I did the same analysis of my 8-inch f/8 with 10 inch ID tube with the same results.
Any thoughts?
Doug Scobel
As you can see from the diagram, there are no light rays that can reflect off the inside of the tube (red lines), strike the primary mirror, and end up in the focal disk. If they do reflect off the inside of the tube, then they’ll miss the focal disk. In other words, no part of the inside of the tube is visible from the focal plane. All such rays would have to reflect twice off the inside of the tube, which is no biggie. Simple flat black paint would be fine – even at 5% reflectance, two reflections would result in only .0025% of the light reaching the focal disk.
Am I looking at this correctly? If I am, then putting annular baffles inside the tube do nothing. But, I think it would be advantageous to add a baffle at the open end of the tube to prevent seeing the sky itself.
FWIW, I did the same analysis of my 8-inch f/8 with 10 inch ID tube with the same results.
Any thoughts?
Doug Scobel
Attached Image: