building a rumak ota??

Started by glennd, 01/13/2008 11:46PM
Posted 01/13/2008 11:46PM | Edited 01/14/2008 12:53AM Opening Post
hi all,
i've been thinking about finding a 6" f/12 or so rumak optics set and building a tube for it. i don't know much about the design though and would like to find a good source on it. in addition to finding a source, one question i have right now is if i was willing to give up some focusing range, could i use an external focuser rather than a moving mirror focuser? the point of the exercise (aside from having fun) would be to build a vented corrector cell and install fan(s?) in the rear cell.
thanks,
glenn
Posted 01/14/2008 03:19AM #1
Hello:

A good reference on this design, and other related designs, is "Telescope Optics: Evaluation and Design" by Rutten & van Venrooij. The Rumak design is named after Rutten. This is a very good book, and well worth getting.

Getting to your second question, the answer is yes, you can use a regular focuser rather than a moving mirror. Actually, it's technically better to use a regular focuser than a moving mirror. This is because the design of the scope is only properly corrected for spherical aberration for one value for the separation between the primary and secondary mirror (at least in the case of a regular Cassegrain, for something like a Rumak, the separation from the corrector to the primary mirror also affects the off axis image quality). A moving primary mirror allows you to move the focal plane back and forth a lot, but at the cost of introducing a little spherical aberration. The advantage of the Rumak design is that you have better control of coma. A disadvantage in my mind, versus something like a Gregory Maksutov, is that when you make a Rumak you have to test and figure the tiny secondary mirror, which will only be 2" or so in diameter. A lot of the other parts, like the baffle tube and the secondary mirror cell, get quite small. If you want to make vented lens cells, then I think that a Gregory Maksutov would be easier to make. Or how about a classical cassegrain, where there's no problem with ventilation up front!

Cheers
Mike Connelley