Hello:
I had an idea regarding collimation. The problem I'm trying to solve is to build a ball scope (like a portaball) with the mirror as far back as possible to minimize the need for counterweights (this is for a 20" mirror, so the scope will already be heavy). One way to do this is to incorporate the mirror cell into the ball itself. However, then you can't tilt the mirror in the ball. The solution I came up with is to tilt the whole ball relative to the truss. I imagine putting a set of push-pull screws at each of the three points where the truss meets the ball. Some care would be required to make sure that the truss attachments remain strong during the adjustment, and can't twist or tilt. One way to ensure this is to have three push screws for each attachment in a little triange pattern, with the pull screw in the middle of them.
So, what do y'all think? Have I missed something? As far as I can tell, it should work. However, a little flexture or instability would be at least frustrating, and at worst disaterous. It would be a lot simpler to put in a regular mirror cell, but I figure that would cost about 100 inch-pounds of torque (which, coincidentally, is about the torque generated by the 31mm Nagler up top).
Cheers
Mike Connelley
I had an idea regarding collimation. The problem I'm trying to solve is to build a ball scope (like a portaball) with the mirror as far back as possible to minimize the need for counterweights (this is for a 20" mirror, so the scope will already be heavy). One way to do this is to incorporate the mirror cell into the ball itself. However, then you can't tilt the mirror in the ball. The solution I came up with is to tilt the whole ball relative to the truss. I imagine putting a set of push-pull screws at each of the three points where the truss meets the ball. Some care would be required to make sure that the truss attachments remain strong during the adjustment, and can't twist or tilt. One way to ensure this is to have three push screws for each attachment in a little triange pattern, with the pull screw in the middle of them.
So, what do y'all think? Have I missed something? As far as I can tell, it should work. However, a little flexture or instability would be at least frustrating, and at worst disaterous. It would be a lot simpler to put in a regular mirror cell, but I figure that would cost about 100 inch-pounds of torque (which, coincidentally, is about the torque generated by the 31mm Nagler up top).
Cheers
Mike Connelley