Cooling idea - great or nuts?

Started by hakescl, 05/04/2004 01:40AM
Posted 05/04/2004 01:40AM Opening Post
Reading some recent posts got me wondering...

Why not attach aluminum (or some other high-heat-conduction metal) fins to the back side of a mirror using whatever appropriate thermal grease. Think of your computer CPU. In this case the supports would need to be "taller" than usual, and go through those cooling fins to reach the glass. Fans would then be just that much more effective.

Has anyone tried this? Why not? Is this idea totally whacko? Or do I need to run down to the patent office?

later,
Charlie

Fort Lewis Observatory: (37.238, -108.052) ~2360m (7744 ft.) elevation.
Darkness - typically 6.5+
Scope - Meade 16" LX200; f6.3 focal reducer
Focus - JMI Smart focus
Camera - SBIG ST-10XE; (~.5"/pixel)
Guiding - AO-8 and/or Meade 5"/DSI/PHD
http://www.fortlewis.edu/observatory
Posted 05/04/2004 02:10AM #1
In truth, I don't know why there is SO much fuss over cooling. But then, I keep my scopes in the garage which is almost the same temp as outside the garage. I suppose I could put my Mak in the fridge for 5 minutes to cool it too, but I suppose the idea is not to just COOL it, but to make it the same temperature as the outside air.

Also it seems increasingly that people want to remove the thermal boundary layer, proven to exist and to linger on there even when a rear fan (or heat sync, which is the term you are looking for) does nothing about. Glass needs to come to the outside temperature. Tube currents and thermal boundaries need to be blown off or out. A heat sync won't do that, but it might produce a measurable increase in getting the glass temp to = the air temp. I don't see why not even though it is a weird idea wink

PS. My wife sticks forks in sweet potatoes to make them bake faster..leaves them in while baking I mean, for pretty much the same reason.

TomL
Posted 05/04/2004 03:10AM #2
Charlie,

With a fan below the mirror, I think the fins could help. It would be worth exploring in my opinion. I have not tried it myself though. Without a fan, the fins on the bottom may hinder air movement because the hotter air would rise up between the fins and be somewhat trapped. Without a fan, you would want the fins on top where heat rises away from the fins. But of course that's on the wrong (mirror) side.

Another nutty idea is to have some aluminum bars thermally attached to the glass that would extend outside of the telescope and into an ice bath or dry ice container. What was the number to that patent office? smile

Mike
Posted 05/04/2004 11:34PM #3
Theory vs. practice:

Would the additional active cooling from this type of radiator cause distortion in the mirror surface?

Is it possible that cooling a mirror too fast could damage it if it was too thin for its mass?

Flip side, if the entire mirror were aluminized rather than just the optical face, would the extra area be an effective radiator?

Failure analysis is one step away from paranoia... but which way?

-Guy

"I know engineers. They love to change things."

- Leonard McCoy (Star Trek: The Motion Picture)