Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Difference between pirex and plate mirror

Started by moutinho, 07/17/2004 07:38PM
Posted 07/17/2004 07:38PM Opening Post
Hi,

What is the difference between a pirex and a plate mirror ?
And if their figure are equal ?
Thanks,
Andre
Posted 07/17/2004 07:54PM #1
Depends. If you are in a temperate climate with mederate temperature swings the plate will probably be fine. If the conditions are more harsh maybe pyrex would be better. I say "maybe" because the tube current problems would most likely be more prominent than any expansion/contraction factors in the glass.
I live in FL and have made several mirrors, both pyrex and plate, and have never had a problem with either that was temperature difference related. I have found that plate is faster to polish but a pyrex polish is superior. Also, plate is much easier to scratch than pyrex.
Hope this helps.

Walt
Posted 07/19/2004 08:28PM #2
There was a discussion of this on the Zambuto Yahoo group a while back. If I recall, Carl said that the biggest difference to him was that Pyrex was a bit easier to figure because you didn't have to worry as much about the glass being fully cooled before testing, since it doesn't expand as much. With plate, you have to be sure the glass has fully cooled after each polishing step before testing it. Also, getting too hot during polishing from friction will cause more problems than with pyrex, again due to the expansion. But, if it is figured properly (i.e. slowly so as not to heat it during figuring), he felt plate glass performed just as well.

Again, this is from memory, so go check out the Zambuto Yahoo group archive to get the details.

Jarad