Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

First Light from the Humble Space Telescope

Started by zonule, 12/24/2003 07:40PM
Posted 12/24/2003 07:40PM Opening Post
Greetings to everyone. I just had to unveil the “Humble Space Telescope” to someone who would understand. I have lurked here for a while, enjoying the discussions and stealing a few ideas. I have loved telescopes since childhood, 40-some years ago, and built quite a few. But never one this large, and never one that used modern Dobsonian techniques. Also, I invested in a few nice eyepieces: a 22mm Panoptic and a 30mm 1RPD.

The design is conventional K&B, with design assisted by NEWT and PLOP. The optics (12.5” F5.25) were bought second-hand - more about this later. The rest I built over the last six months. In the process, I learned to weld, and use a milling machine, router, and lathe from indulgent co-workers. Not a bad way to pick up some new skills!

First a few observations:

WOW! This is a whole different experience from what I am used to. The wide views and bright images are astonishing. The Pleiades looked like bright blue diamonds sprinkled across velvet. The Great Orion Nebula filled the Panoptic with festoons and streamers out the edge of the field. The combination of large aperture and excellent eyepieces makes a real difference. (I had hoped it would.) It’s hard to go back to standard Plossl performance after this; like looking down a hole rather than a window.

Now the questions:

1) Should I invest in refiguring the primary? The images are generally pleasing except for very bright stars and planets. There I see a large amount of haze around these objects, almost as if the eyepiece is dewing up. Definition is not as good as I am used to from my old 8” F8. I think the collimation is OK, but I haven’t yet made a Barlowed laser.

The 12.5 inch mirror is obviously amateur-made: it’s thin (about 1”) and has no commercial markings. There is a problem with incomplete polishing: a hazy annulus around the outer 2” of the mirror face – not really obvious unless the illumination is right. I think I know the answer, but is this the source of halos visible around bright objects? I would cheerfully pay someone like Swayze or Royce to fix it. (OK, I would grumble, but this scope is a keeper.) Would improving the polish be worth the cost?

2) The Dobsonian motions are wonderfully smooth, even “buttery”, but a bit too much force is required. I should note that the temperature is typical for Minnesota: COLD. What do people think of silicone or dry lube? Does this gum up the works or make the force undesirably low? (The scope has Ebony Star with Teflon bearings.)

3) I notice that aluminum truss tubes are frequently covered with foam. Is this merely to protect fingers from the cold, or does the cold metal create turbulence in the light path?

See you later, all. I need to help get Christmas ready.

Gary Hansen





Attached Image:

zonule's attachment for post 11725
Posted 12/24/2003 08:33PM #1
Hello Gary, I like your scope. I have a few comments on your questions, I hope it helps:

1) I just wanted to ask you about dew on the secondary. You may need a dew extension (a tube of kydex at the front of the scope put on with velcro strips)/and or some dew fighting heater (like Kendrick's Dew Systems, or Astrosystems Dewguard to help keep off dew from the secondary. I found in winter time my secondary was dewing up, and it showed up in the eyepiece as glare around bright objects like planets, moon, ect.

2) Dave Kriege in his book recommends car was on the laminates (then buff), then a coat of Armor-all after that. It does make it slicker.

3) The black foam has two other functions:

-it reflects less stray light into the optical path compared with the glare of the metal on the bare poles and

- is supposed to help with damping of vibrations from the poles, so less jiggle at the eyepiece.

Brien
Posted 12/24/2003 11:21PM #2
Well, I would like to address a couple of your questions.
It is not uncommon to look at the mirror from an angle with a light and see what would appear to be a hazy ring around the mirror. I asked Steve Swazye about this and his comment was "If the reflection looks clear and bright when you look down into the mirror box, then it is OK".
From the picture you have posted of the mirror it looks pretty good.
It is possible that the hazy ring around the images is cause by conditions or dew on the secondary or the EPs. Remember, it is easy to get dew on the EPs when it is cold out like now. Your eye will fog it sometimes.
Make sure the collimation is dead on before you make any judgements about the optics. Check everything twice.
It could be worthwhile getting it refigured by Steve Swayze, if the mirror cell is supporting the 1" glass properly. If not then you would need to invest in a new mirror cell as well. The cell looks fine in the picture however, being an 18 point should be perfect for the thin mirror. Is it a sling too?
Paint the truss tubes with flat black epoxy paint and they will look great and keep down reflections. The foam is just one way of doing this, but the thicker tubes are harder to store. I made a pouch with 8 sleeves to hold all my truss tubes plus 2 sleeves for my collimation tubes.
The scope looks great! Nice work, give it a few tries before you make up your mind what to do.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 12/25/2003 10:00PM #3
I suggest you get someone with a tester to test the mirror or carefully startest it in good seeing at high power.

Large plate mirrors cool slower and it may be fine.

I can say from experience if you see minor greyness on the mirror it will cause some scattering around bright objects.

I did an early 6 inch f-9 mirror that showed this and when I repolished it further the smog around stars disapeared so yes greyness causes the effect you describe.

Of course its hard to say from your description how bad it is.

You have a very good mirror support going and truss design well done. I recently built a similar 13.3 inch instrument with my own mirror. It is 45mm thick BVC and blows away an 8 inch newt in good seeing as it should but takes some time to cool.

The fact the mirror is thin plate isn't a problem I've seen a 20 inch 19mm thick plate mirror work superbly but its maker was a master of the art and it was very nicely supported.

The suggestion of getting the mirror refigured by a master like Mr Swayze is a good one. He does this at very reasonable cost and I've seen his workmanship first hand he knows what he's doing.



Posted 12/25/2003 10:16PM #4
Very nice job. I, too, am getting ready to start my 12.5" truss dob. It's an f/4.8, so it will be a little shorter. I like the mirror cell.

Thanks for the post and motivation.

Clear skies (and cold),

Tim H.