Focuser and focal length.

Started by explore, 10/07/2003 03:36PM
Posted 10/07/2003 03:36PM Opening Post
Oh man, where do I begin. Ok, I just ordered a 10" F/4.8 dob. This will be my second scope, so I don't have much experience. I asked for a 1 1/4" focuser because I haven't decided which 2" focuser I want(FeatherTouch, DX1, DX3, etc.). This week I will finally be able to test out a FeatherTouch. So I figured that after I receive this new dob I would have to do some modifications to it. So here are my questions, and there are many:

1. If I go with the 2" FeatherTouch focuser, is this going to screw up my focal length? Or are 1 1/4" focusers generally the same height as 2" low profile? Am I going to have to move the primary back a little bit away from the secondary? I don't know the height of the 1 1/4" focuser as I haven't received the scope yet.

2. When you are setting the distance from the diagonal to the focal plane, how far out do you rack the focuser? In other words, if I have a FeatherTouch with 2 inches of travel, do I rack it out 1 inch and use that distance? That way I will have one inch of out-focus and one inch of in-focus from the focal plane. Following the same logic, if I had a 2" focuser with 3 inches of travel I would rack it out 1.5" when I go to set the distance. Or is that not correct?

3. Am I doing this correctly? Given these figures: 10" f/4.8 dob with a 12" ID tube, a focuser height of 1.6"(FeatherTouch specs) with 2 inches of travel, and a tube thickness of 1/4", my distance from the diagonal to focal plane should be set at 8.85". 6"(radius of ID of tube) + 1/4"(tube thickness) + 1.6"(focuser height fully racked in) + 1"(middle of travel distance for focuser) = 8.85"

4. I will be using Naglers and Pentax ep's in my scope, as well as a Denk II binoviewer. If I go with the FeatherTouch, which travel length would you recommend? They offer 1.5", 2" and 2.5".

Thanks in advance to anybody who tackles all of these questions.

Posted 10/07/2003 04:39PM #1
Hi Chris,

Given that you don't mind moving the primary mirror, here is a (pretty) simple suggestion that will tackle all your problems at once--

Buy your favorite 2" focuser and see if your eyepieces come to focus. If they do, then smile and be happy.

P.S. But if they don't, then follow these instructions:

Determine if you need to move the primary mirror toward the focuser or away from the focuser. It should be easy to tell because you'll see stars starting to come to focus and then you'll run out of focuser travel. If focus is inside the tube, then advance the primary toward the secondary mirror until your eyepiece reaches focus (31mm and 22mm Naglers are eyepieces that need lots of in-travel, so if you have one of those, you can use it to benchmark). Once you get a 31mm Nagler to come to focus, you can pretty much count on not needing any more in-travel for another eyepiece in the future.

If memory serves, all TeleVue eyepieces come to focus within about 1-3/8" of focus travel, so you should be fine with a 1.5" drawtube, but you can get a 2" if you want to be super safe, though the drawtube may protrude into the light path just a teeny bit (no big deal, IMHO).

I wouldn't choose a 2.5" travel drawtube unless I had a refractor or folded folded refractor where intrusion into the light path isn't likely/possible. In any case, should you go with a 1.5" drawtube and find you don't have enough out-travel after setting up for the big FL Nagler, the eyepieces that generally need more out-travel on TeleVue's list have 1.25" barrels, so you can use a 2" to 1.25" adapter and plug those eyepieces into that to achieve the same result as a longer drawtube.

You should visit TeleVue's website and look at their eyepiece specifications. The spec called "flange level" in column F, I believe, are relative distances for each TV eyepiece where they come to focus relative to each other. So, for example, where a 31mm Nagler has a flange level of -.31 and a 7mm Nagler has a flange level of +.25, this tells you that the 31mm comes to focus .56", more than 1/2", farther in (in-travel) than the 7mm. So, if your 31mm reaches focus when your drawtube is almost all the way racked in, then a 7mm will reach focus with about 1/2+" of room left to spare.

So, to summarize, I'd buy a 2" focuser and any TeleVue eyepiece on that chart and mount the focuser centered on your current secondary mirror and go from there with the primary mirror and cell. You can buy a cheaper TV eyepiece and, using the spec chart, ensure you set the focal plane relative to your focus in/out-travel so future eyepieces will come to focus, i.e. if you buy an eyepiece with a +.50" flange level, then move the primary mirror until the eyepiece reaches focus when the drawtube is about 7/8" racked out to ensure your future 31mm or 22mm will have enough in-travel when you finally buy it.

Anyway, that's my story, and I'm sticking to it ;^).