Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

How Short Can the Upper Cage be?

Started by toml, 11/25/2003 07:42AM
Posted 11/25/2003 07:42AM Opening Post
In building a 13.1" f4/5 truss dob, the Kreige/Berry book recommends 60% of the primary diameter as the minimum height for the upper cage.

Well that comes out to about 8"... But I would like if possible to shave an inch (or two?) off of that if possible. I don't think I'll have a shrowd, but unless a baffle opposite the focuser is avoidable with an 8" or 9" upper cage height, then why bother with 8" at all?

I mean, if I *HAVE* to add a baffle no matter how tall my cage is up there, then why bother making it 8" and why not just have it be smaller and more compact, nesting better for travel and finally, lighter?

So, how low should I go?

Thanks.
Tom.
Posted 11/25/2003 01:47PM #1
Tom, here is a pic of a friends 16" that will fit in a suitcase when disassembled(the whols scope). The secondary cage is about 5" tall. As you can see he adds a shroud at the front. I can testify that it works and gives stupendous images!

Walt

Attached Image:

Walter's attachment for post 73487
Posted 11/25/2003 01:52PM #2
Portaball uses a single ring for the UTA on their 10" and 14.5" scopes. I have also seen plenty of ATM scopes with a "frame only" UTA - no solid tube at all. As long as you add the necessary baffles when it is assembled, the only thing the UTA has to do is hold the focuser and secondary in proper alignment, and without too much vibration.

Jarad
Posted 11/25/2003 03:43PM #3
Tom,
My 12.5 F5 has a single ring of 1/2 inch baltic birch. On one side, I have a right angle strip of aluminum from which I have attached the two inch focuser, and a smaller right angle bracket to hold the base of a Rigel Quickfinder. The other side has four right angle brackets that anchor the spider. There are also screws sticking through these brackets that allow me to anchor an extension of my shroud. That shroud extension stretches out six inches to act as a light shield.

In short--one single ring is all you really need. (I've seen it done with the rim of a bicycle wheel.) However, if you go for this design, remember that your secondary will be hanging down there unprotected, and you will need to arrange for some kind of light shield up top.

Alex
Posted 11/26/2003 03:06AM #4
Well, I see that a single ring definitely requires a piece of baffle opposite the focuser (above AND below? or just above for the most part?)

Now what if I WANT a two ring structure, and wrap Kydex around the whole thing. I would do that if I knew I wouldn't need any additional baffling up there.

How tall would a TWO ring cage (minimally) need to be to pull that off?

Thanks.
Tom.