Is this wild idea possible? (bi-refractor)

Started by BoyntonStu, 04/05/2006 05:14PM
Posted 04/05/2006 05:14PM | Edited 04/05/2006 05:14PM Opening Post
A really wild idea:

Use 2 star diagonals and 2 flat mirrors.

Have the scopes pointing left and right horizontal each looking at a 45 degree mirror to the sky. Like a binocular mirror.

To adjust IPD, move the scopes in or out horizontally.

It would look like this:


\()====== =\ /= ======()/



Stu
Posted 04/05/2006 05:51PM #1
Stu Lieberman said:

A really wild idea:

Use 2 star diagonals and 2 flat mirrors.

Have the scopes pointing left and right horizontal each looking at a 45 degree mirror to the sky. Like a binocular mirror.

To adjust IPD, move the scopes in or out horizontally.

It would look like this:

()====== = /= ======()/

Stu

No question that it would work - but WHY?
Posted 04/05/2006 08:40PM #2
This reminds me of rangefinder binoculars that were sold many years ago. They had long barrels with right-angled prisms at the objectives. There was a hinge at the center so you could use them either like a binocular periscope (barrels together) or a rangefinder (barrels 180 degrees apart). In the second configuration, the objectives would be about 2 or 3 feet apart.
Posted 04/06/2006 02:22AM #3
Well, on first glance it's a crazy idea, but then after a while the benefits begin to surface.

Both scopes are horizontal so won't have differential balance issues due to altitue etc. Altitude rotation can be either well-supported scope(s) or front mirror(s). The whole structure rotates on an azimuth table. Easier co-collimation mechanism than long, cantilevered OTA(s). To adjust IPD just use the built-in focuser(s). Fine-focus with a helical inserted into the back diagonal(s). Viewing height is constant, but viewing angle is not so good unless you added another diagonal. Availability and cost of large, high quality elliptical front mirror(s) limit aperture to 4" or less, unless you ground your own.

-- William
Posted 04/06/2006 08:30PM #4
Stu,

Since you and I both seem to be fascinated by bizarro telescope designs, you may be interested to hear about the "Alphorn" telescope I built several years ago. (This was inspired by the Porter turret telescope where the eyepiece stays in a fixed location.) The Alphorn scope was a small refractor with TWO optical flats in front of the objective. These flats allowed you to see any point in the sky while the eyepiece did not move. The tube was always pointed down along the polar axis. I built a mechanism employing a bicycle chain so I could turn one of the mirrors while seated at the eyepiece without reaching way down near the ground where the mirrors were located.

I gave it the name "Alphorn" after the musical instrument it vaguely resembled.

The scope was a dismal failure. Not only was it big and clumsy, but it was nearly impossible to find anything with it. I mounted a right-angle finder scope on the stubby little tube holding the first mirror, but this didn't help much.

Hope you have better luck with your ideas!