Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mak Cass to Mak Newt Conversion Question

Started by Gene, 03/07/2005 02:49AM
Posted 03/07/2005 02:49AM Opening Post
I have a large ATM Maksutov Cassegrain project that's around f/6.5. Before I finish this out I'm curious if it's possible to use the same corrector and primary but just switch the secondary and make it a Mak Newt...

Has anyone ever tried this on a slow Mak Cass design -- or is it simply not going to work due to the correction of the meniscus? Note: The secondary is not a spot on the meniscus but an actual secondary mirror with no magnification.
Posted 03/08/2005 03:19AM #1
Hello:
In your case, it should work. From what you say, your secondary mirror is a flat. In this case, the telescope performance doesn't depend on the tilt of the flat. With a Newtonian configuration, you should be able to get your central obstruction to less than 20%. The one possible problem I see is that (as far as I know) the meniscus lens must be a specified distance from the primary mirror. Hopefully the Newtonian secondary can be closer to the primary than the lens, or else you'll have to punch a hole through your lens or grind the lens to a different prescription.

Cheers
Mike Connelley
Posted 03/09/2005 10:41PM #2
Gene Griggs said:

I have a large ATM Maksutov Cassegrain project that's around f/6.5. Before I finish this out I'm curious if it's possible to use the same corrector and primary but just switch the secondary and make it a Mak Newt...

Has anyone ever tried this on a slow Mak Cass design -- or is it simply not going to work due to the correction of the meniscus? Note: The secondary is not a spot on the meniscus but an actual secondary mirror with no magnification.

Are you saying that your Mak-Cass is designed with flat secondary? That would be highly unusual, because either results in inaccessible focus, or requires >50% obstruction to make it accessible. Also, it makes hard to correct for coma, since corrector alone cannot generate enough coma to correct the opposite coma of the primary (unless the corrector is placed closer to primary's r.o.c., making the system long)

If the secondary is flat, then all the correction for spherical aberration is at the corrector/primary, and you could use any configuration with a flat secondary mirror you want. If (spherical) secondary is curved, then it takes part in system's spherical correction, which means that replacing it with a flat would result in a system with significant undercorrection.

Vlad