Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

making a f8 8inch with a diagonal ?

Started by faintfuzzies, 07/24/2009 11:58AM
Posted 07/24/2009 11:58AM Opening Post
I have a 8 inch f 8 scope to make for my hand made mirror. but i have a eq style mount so the eyepiece will be way to high at times. so what i wanted to do is try to make the scope so i can use a diagonal on it .this should allow me to observe more comfortably in those afull tuff postions . but i dont know if it will work well, and im not really sure how to figure in the diagonal. any ideas would be great

Thanks
Posted 07/24/2009 02:24PM #1
Louis Del Sesto III said:

I have a 8 inch f 8 scope to make for my hand made mirror. but i have a eq style mount so the eyepiece will be way to high at times. so what i wanted to do is try to make the scope so i can use a diagonal on it .this should allow me to observe more comfortably in those afull tuff postions . but i dont know if it will work well, and im not really sure how to figure in the diagonal. any ideas would be great

Thanks

Louis:

The difficulty with using a diagonal to shorten the OTA length and make the scope more comfortable to use is that it has to be quite large, thus negating a primary advantage of the F/8 focal ratio.

To determine the size, you can download Newtwin:
http://www.dalekeller.net/ATM/newtonians/newtsoft/newtsoft.htm

You can play around with it, changing the focuser height to shorten the OTA length and then achieve full illumination.

For example a 10 inch diameter tube with a 0.125 inch wall with a 1.5 inch diagonal and a 3 inch focuser height would be fully illuminated for almost 1/2 a degree, reasonable for a planetary scope. The OTA would be about 65 inches long.

To shorten the tube by about 12 inches, I would just assume a 15 inch focuser height, to achieve a similar fully illuminated field, it would require a diagonal of about 3 inches, a CO of 38%. This results in an OTA about 52 inches long based on the Newtwin defaults, it could be somewhat shorter.

My suggestion would be to consider a DOB mount, that way you can keep the small CO and still keep the scope length manageable. An EQ platform could handle the tracking.

In my experience, even a Newtonian with a 52inch tube can be a bit to manage on a GEM unless one has rotating rings and a nice short pier mount. And even then the viewing positions can be quite awkward.

Just a few thoughts...

Jon