Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mirror Box Cutaway Sketch

Started by toml, 01/24/2005 08:06PM
Posted 01/24/2005 08:06PM | Edited 01/24/2005 08:40PM Opening Post
Hi Everybody.
It seems that I wasn't quite clear on what I was getting at with my "cutaway" thought of the day yesterday. First of all, naturally I know the reason for the cutaway is to lower the height of the MB in the rocker box. The arc of the swing through (which is what I actually wound up cutting yesterday) is therefore the minimum cutout.

But what my posting was getting at was that I noticed that a 45 cut lands a lot higher (about twice as high) up the side meeting the front. That got me thinking about weight/strength issues and tradeoffs. Which led to the thought of the most radical cutout of all: all the way to the top corner.

That was what I was ruminating about out loud.

Somebody replied that this would be too weak if you went over 45, but I think I must have not been clear or misunderstood, because I believe the opposite is true: even though I decided on box #2 in the sketch, what I was getting at (box #4) was that the front of that box would clear the swingthrough and be stronger, not weaker than a 45 (box #3) or the minimal arc (#2).

Yet I've never seen a box #4 (like I said, it came from a "question everything" moment), so maybe it's just me and I'm crazy shocked

Well I definitely know I'm bored to bits to bother scanning my sketch but there is truly NOTHING going on at work today, so just for academic discussion, I give you my kookie idea I was unable to parlay clearly yesterday:

All the best (hope your day isn't as boring as mine)
TomL

Attached Image:

toml's attachment for post 21746
Posted 01/26/2005 10:33PM #1
Hi Tom,

Just a few comments (for academic discussion) on your idea. smile First of all, a 45 cut doesn't necessarily end up a lot higher up the mirror box than a curved cut. It depends on the height of the mirror box (the center of gravity, actually).

As for a larger cut weakening the mirrror box, I think it depends on what you do with the cut away section. If it is left open, then yes, the MB is weaker. If you fill it with plywood (or whatever material you are using), then it should be just as strong.

My only other thought about Box #4 is a lot of dobs use the flat piece as a stop. The front of the MB hits the front of the rocker box and keeps the scope from going past vertical. It's not too big of a difficulty to overcome, and maybe not even necessary. Just some thoughts. smile

Kevin
Posted 01/31/2005 06:59AM #2
I agree that the 45 degree cut should not end up any higher than the arc cut. If you want the 45 degree cut that allows the same lowering of the box as the arc cut, then it must have the same beginning and ending points.

The part that has been left out of the conversation so far is what is happening inside the mirror box. Keep in mind that you need to have room for the cell and mirror. This is the problem I see with your box #4. The cut is at such a shallow angle that it would be hard to leave room for the mirror without making a bigger box. This is the advantage of the 45 degree cut: it allows most of the cutaway to occur in the wasted space below the cell. (Of course, the arc leaves the most room of all allowing for a smaller box and/or a lower placement of the mirror.)