Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mirror making - how to remove central hole?

Started by djscobel, 02/28/2006 03:32PM
Posted 02/28/2006 03:32PM | Edited 02/28/2006 10:25PM Opening Post
Hi, all, I'm working on a 6" f/4.5 mirror. All polished out, attempting to figure.

The mirror has a large and deep central depression, roughly 3.5" in diameter. It's left over from an earlier attempt to parabolize with a too-hard lap (too much overhang, long strokes, hard lap, result - dug a deep hole). The outer zones are relatively flat.

What is the best way to eliminate it? Some books say stick with 1/3 diameter center over center strokes, with mirror on top, and eventually it will work itself out. Others say it's best to use a deformed lap, depressing the central facets using a circle of waxed paper a little smaller than the depression while pressing. I want to concentrate the action in the outer zones, but I don't want to create some other defect that will make matters worse, like turning the edge.

Any ideas?

Thanks,
Doug
Posted 03/01/2006 01:08PM #1
I decided that deforming the lap was too scary, so I'm going with the 1/3 COC strokes, MOT. After an hour's worth of work (actual polishing time) last night it's leveling out nicely. I figure another two hours or so will do it.

Doug
Posted 03/01/2006 11:51PM #2
Do some of the work with the TOT. TOT will "remove" the edge of the mirror. Which is what you want since you have a hole. This might speed up the process. Good luck. Secret of mirror making is to stay with it. Bill
Posted 03/04/2006 02:07PM #3
I've made a few mirrors over my lifetime, but it seems that they're getting more and more difficult for me, rather than easier. It's not the grinding and polishing, it's figuring. The lap just doesn't want to do anything I want it to. The first two mirrors I made (in my teens) were in the summertime in my garage. I never had the kind of problems I have now. Those two mirrors, a 6" f/9 and a 6" f/4.5, polished out nicely, and parabolizing with the full size lap was a snap – worked just like the books described. But now, I have a devil of a time getting the lap to do anything reasonable. For instance, using a 1/3 diameter W stroke always results in a flat edge zone, and a large central hill. The flat zone's width is about the same as the overhang, about 3/4 inch on a 6" mirror. Longer strokes with more overhang just result in a wider "flat" outer zone, but still with a central bump. Forget parabolizing with a full size lap – I have to get way too aggressive with the strokes and then end up digging a deep, ugly hole in the middle. I had to resort to a 4" lap to parabolize my last mirror, an 8" f/8. But getting a decent sphere first was problematic. Now I'm having similar problems with my current project, a 6" f/4.5 (see earlier posts).

Knowing that my earlier mirrors were done in much warmer temperatures and higher humidity, could the low temperature and humidity in my house be making the lap too hard? With the price of natural gas these days, I simply can't afford to keep the house any warmer than 70 degrees. And with forced air heat, the humidity is way low, even with a whole house humidifier. I think I'm maintaining good contact, I hot press, cold press, use netting, warm the lap and start polishing before it has cooled off all the way, etc., and the lap's action feels smooth, not jerky. But still I end up with weird results. I'm using Gugolz 64 pitch, but I'm wondering if it is still too hard. But even if it is hard, shouldn't that be conducive to getting a good sphere? If I could get a good sphere I'd be happy. I'm fine with using a 3" lap to parabolize – the sub-diameter lap worked great on my 8" mirror.

I'm tempted to make a new lap, adding some turpentine to soften it up. Or I could order some Gugolz 55. Or try raising the house temperature by maybe five degrees, at least temporarily. (Yeah, try rationalizing that to my wife, who is always complaining that the house is too cold. "But it's for my mirror". Yeah, that will fly.) Or maybe I've just developed some unorthodoxy in my technique that I'm not even aware of.

This is getting really frustrating. :C Any and all suggestions are welcome.

Thanks,
Doug