Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Piano wire spider

Started by tomrod, 04/15/2003 03:59PM
Posted 04/15/2003 03:59PM Opening Post
Has anyone tried suspending the secondary using paino wire? I have some thoughts on a design, but I would like any information I can get from those who have tried before.

There are only 10 kinds of people who understand binary - those that do and those that don't
Posted 04/15/2003 04:03PM #1
I've thought about using videotape but have never tried it. Vibration could be a problem.
Posted 04/15/2003 04:45PM #2
I asked this question about a year ago, but didn't find anyone who had actually tried it. (I still haven't, either. smile ) The suggested problem was getting the support strong enough to hold the tension, which would have to be rather high. You would also need a way to tighten the wire - just like a guitar.

Let me know how yours turns out. Good luck!

Charlie

Fort Lewis Observatory: (37.238, -108.052) ~2360m (7744 ft.) elevation.
Darkness - typically 6.5+
Scope - Meade 16" LX200; f6.3 focal reducer
Focus - JMI Smart focus
Camera - SBIG ST-10XE; (~.5"/pixel)
Guiding - AO-8 and/or Meade 5"/DSI/PHD
http://www.fortlewis.edu/observatory
Posted 04/15/2003 07:47PM #3
I made one once for a 10" f9.5, according to a design in Sky & Tel that appeared quite a number of years ago. The diffraction spikes were far more obvious and annoying than the vanilla Novak 4 vane spider I had in the scope before. (I put both in for a while to be sure, with the Novak at 45 degrees to the other.) It was a big disappointment.

If you have two wires on any one leg, even if they are perfectly lined up on axis, a little off-axis you have two wires.
Posted 04/15/2003 11:18PM #4
The design I had in mind was two wires on the top and two wires on the bottom, perpendicular to the ones in the top. I also envisioned using a very good vibration damping material in the outer mounting platforms to reduce vibration and tension requirements.

I don’t know the theory behind diffraction spikes, but according to my calculations a 1" high strip tilted 1 degree will present a 0.035" obstruction. My calculations are always suspect since Excel uses radians and I often do not convert properly. The only reason I would use a wire spider is if the height of a thin metal spider contributes to the diffraction spike.

There are only 10 kinds of people who understand binary - those that do and those that don't