Would anyone happen have any suggestions on how to determine if a primary mirror is made from pyrex or plate glass other than taking the manufacture's word for it.
Pyrex or plate glass
Started by zengalaxy, 10/17/2004 09:46PM
Posted 10/17/2004 09:46PM
Opening Post
Posted 10/17/2004 10:12PM
#1
Sometimes color will help.
Plate glass is generally distinguishable by having a faint green color, most noticable when you look at the edge of a piece.
Pyrex is generally colorless or slightly grey in color; older Pyrex can be yellow-ish (straw colored).
But also weight will tell the type, but you must know the sizes to figure that.
Pyrex Density is 2.23 (g/cm3)
Floyd
Plate glass is generally distinguishable by having a faint green color, most noticable when you look at the edge of a piece.
Pyrex is generally colorless or slightly grey in color; older Pyrex can be yellow-ish (straw colored).
But also weight will tell the type, but you must know the sizes to figure that.
Pyrex Density is 2.23 (g/cm3)
Floyd
[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue
Amateur Imager
Posted 10/19/2004 02:35PM
| Edited 10/19/2004 02:38PM
#3
According to
http://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/Star/compos.pl?matno=169 and
http://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/Star/compos.pl?matno=171
Pyrex and plate glasses have the following composition (by weight):
Pyrex
Boron -- 0.040064
Oxygen -- 0.539562
Sodium -- 0.028191
Aluminum -- 0.011644
Silicon -- 0.377220
Potassium -- 0.003321
Plate
Oxygen -- 0.459800
Sodium -- 0.096441
Silicon -- 0.336553
Calcium -- 0.107205
My guess is that real proof would require minor damage to the mirror. Either grinding off a small sample for chemical analysis, or testing with a substance that would corrode plate glass but not pyrex. I believe that flame photometry might easily give the answer, if you can find a chemist with the right equipment. Perhaps a glass recycler could help.
http://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/Star/compos.pl?matno=169 and
http://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/Star/compos.pl?matno=171
Pyrex and plate glasses have the following composition (by weight):
Pyrex
Boron -- 0.040064
Oxygen -- 0.539562
Sodium -- 0.028191
Aluminum -- 0.011644
Silicon -- 0.377220
Potassium -- 0.003321
Plate
Oxygen -- 0.459800
Sodium -- 0.096441
Silicon -- 0.336553
Calcium -- 0.107205
My guess is that real proof would require minor damage to the mirror. Either grinding off a small sample for chemical analysis, or testing with a substance that would corrode plate glass but not pyrex. I believe that flame photometry might easily give the answer, if you can find a chemist with the right equipment. Perhaps a glass recycler could help.
Funding Member