Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Re: Secondary Too Bukoo?

Started by [email protected], 05/09/2006 08:23AM
Posted 05/09/2006 08:23AM Opening Post
Hello:
Let's say you have a 3" high focuser and 1" between the tube and the mirror, which gives 9 inches from the optical axis to the focal plane. In order to get all of the light in the center of the field of view, you need at least a 1.8" secondary. Using one so small isn't such a good idea since you'll loose quite a bit of light at the edge of your field of view, and the edge of the mirror probably won't be very good. A 2.14" secondary will give you a fully illuminated fied of around 0.3", which is okay but kind of small in my book, especially since you've shelled out the big $ to see a 2" focal plane. So, a 2.6" secondary isn't too big if you're interested in wide field deep sky faint fuzzy work. If you're interested in mainly planetary viewing, then something smaller would be better. In the end, I doubt that there's any observable difference between a 2.1" and 2.6" secondary.

Cheers
Mike Connelley
Posted 05/09/2006 05:25PM #1
Michael,
How about the Vignetting with the 2.6" secondary at the focuser? This seems like it would be a problem to me.
The 2.1" would seem to be the better choice for this if you are looking for a larger illuminated field.
My 14.5" Starmaster has a 2.6" secondary, my 15" Dob had a 2.6" secondary as well. Both perform very well with this sized mirror. I also had a 2.6" mirror in the Orion 10" XTi and it worked well enough, but was larger than needed.
But my 10" f/6 Dob uses a 1.83" secondary and the DSO as well as planetary views are exceptional. I use all the way up to a 31mm Nagler with good results. 100% illumination is .35° with diameter of .36 inch. 75% illumination is 1.101° and diameter is 1.115 inch.
With a 2.1" the 100% is .65° and .63 inch and 75% is 1.39° and 1.45 inch. So double that of the 1.83"
But the 2.6" doubles this all again and with vignetting, this seems to be just too big of a secondary to me.
According to Kriege and Berry's book, a DSO scope would want around a 20mm 100% Illuminated field or .78" so that the 2.1 is much closer to this than the 2.6". However, they also state that a smaller secondary will not cause any great loss, only a small amount in the longest f/l EPs. They discuss a 3.5" secondary for the 20" scope being replaced with a 3.1" secondary with no real loss. So if a 3.1" is large enough for a 20" scope, the a 2.6" seems rather large for a 10" mirror to me.
The height of the focuser is a big part of this equation. So the actual height of the focuser at focus with your EPs is a big consideration. smile

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager