Replacing Criterion mirror RV-6

Started by ccather, 01/16/2005 12:24PM
Posted 01/16/2005 12:24PM Opening Post
I am restoring a 1977 Criterion RV-6.

The mirror must be replaced (6" and f/8). The my budget is $200 for the mirror. Orion has one for $99 and Parks $190. Is Parks mirror $100 better?
Posted 01/16/2005 05:17PM #1
Charles, That is a good question for which there are no easy answers.
I have a scope made using one of the Orion 6" f/6.7 mirrors and am very pleased with it. For 90.00 it would be hard to beat no matter what the cost. A friend has an Orion 6" f/8 ota that gives very good images.
The other side of the coin is the repeatability from one sample to the next. I haven't seen any outright bashing of Orion mirrors on AM and Lord knows there must be hundreds or even thousands of them out there. I don't think Parks makes there own mirrors so there is no real guarantee their mirror would be better. Price is not ALWAYS a positive factor wink
Personally, I would go for the Orion. If you get a lemon, give me a call - after you have called Orion to return it. They have an excellent reputation for customer service.

Walt