This is my first mirror and I think that I have solved most of my problems, but I have a “zone” problem that has me stumped. I am hoping an old hand will say, “Oh that’s just so-and-so. If you do this the zone should go away in 3-4 hours.”
Background
I am polishing a 10" F:7 BVC mirror. I am using an Edmunds Optical glass grating 150 lines per inch. The tester is a slitless/LED/green apparatus where the grating and LED
move together. I polished 20 hours on pads and about 15 - 20 hours pitch.( Third lap). I think I have a great finish,but "The Zone" has tripled my time. I have had straight lines several times throughout the previous weeks and would have considered the mirror spherical and ready for parabolizing except for the Zone.
The Zone
After having polished for about 2 hours on the pads, I noticed that when I moved the tester to .5" inside the ROC that all of the lines in the image disappeared. Similarly,
about the same distance outside the ROC I got the same total lack of information --100% "blurred". I am calling this total blurring at .5" --"The Zone". My problem is seems to be centered on what happens at one unique position of the tester itself with respect to the ROC and why the lines disappear only at one location . I am getting 5 very nice lines around .34" which seems to agree with Ronchiz software. The Zone exists for about .1" of travel either side of .5"
My Theory
I originally assumed that this phenomenon was due to the pads and that the pitch would take care of it. About three weeks ago, after pouring over hundreds of threads on the Net , I came to the conclusion that what I had is what very experienced people in this and another forum call "two radii" or " a sphere within a sphere". I started to treat the problem as one of pushing the inner sphere out to the edge.
The Theory Crashes
In the last 10 hours of alternating pads and pitch, I have made some improvements. But "The Zone" still lives at around .5". So I made two cardboard masks in order to determine the location of the cause of the Zone. One was 6" in diameter which I put in the center of the mirror and one was a 2" wide ring which I used to mask off the outer 2" of the mirror. My theory was that one of these masks would tell me where the transition ridge lived. I have been assuming all along that If there were two radii that the transition area would be located in the outer 1" - 2".
So, when I used the 6" central mask I saw the Zone again at around .5". Okay, I thought, so the problem lives in the outer 2" of the disc. Then I taped on the outer 2" mask, but the zone was still there. Surely one of the masks would have eliminated the blurring. Obviously I have not grasped some fundamental property of how mirrors reflect images.
Conclusion
So, why did not one of the masks eliminate the blurring? Where is the transition zone, if in fact, there is one? Any ideas? Thanks in advance.
Background
I am polishing a 10" F:7 BVC mirror. I am using an Edmunds Optical glass grating 150 lines per inch. The tester is a slitless/LED/green apparatus where the grating and LED
move together. I polished 20 hours on pads and about 15 - 20 hours pitch.( Third lap). I think I have a great finish,but "The Zone" has tripled my time. I have had straight lines several times throughout the previous weeks and would have considered the mirror spherical and ready for parabolizing except for the Zone.
The Zone
After having polished for about 2 hours on the pads, I noticed that when I moved the tester to .5" inside the ROC that all of the lines in the image disappeared. Similarly,
about the same distance outside the ROC I got the same total lack of information --100% "blurred". I am calling this total blurring at .5" --"The Zone". My problem is seems to be centered on what happens at one unique position of the tester itself with respect to the ROC and why the lines disappear only at one location . I am getting 5 very nice lines around .34" which seems to agree with Ronchiz software. The Zone exists for about .1" of travel either side of .5"
My Theory
I originally assumed that this phenomenon was due to the pads and that the pitch would take care of it. About three weeks ago, after pouring over hundreds of threads on the Net , I came to the conclusion that what I had is what very experienced people in this and another forum call "two radii" or " a sphere within a sphere". I started to treat the problem as one of pushing the inner sphere out to the edge.
The Theory Crashes
In the last 10 hours of alternating pads and pitch, I have made some improvements. But "The Zone" still lives at around .5". So I made two cardboard masks in order to determine the location of the cause of the Zone. One was 6" in diameter which I put in the center of the mirror and one was a 2" wide ring which I used to mask off the outer 2" of the mirror. My theory was that one of these masks would tell me where the transition ridge lived. I have been assuming all along that If there were two radii that the transition area would be located in the outer 1" - 2".
So, when I used the 6" central mask I saw the Zone again at around .5". Okay, I thought, so the problem lives in the outer 2" of the disc. Then I taped on the outer 2" mask, but the zone was still there. Surely one of the masks would have eliminated the blurring. Obviously I have not grasped some fundamental property of how mirrors reflect images.
Conclusion
So, why did not one of the masks eliminate the blurring? Where is the transition zone, if in fact, there is one? Any ideas? Thanks in advance.