For a 16" f/4.3, who votes for a 3.1" secondary (19% obstruction) and who votes for a 3.5" (21.9%)? For a f/4.5 scope, most agree that it should be a 3.1". But at f/4.3 my calculation shows that producing only about .45 deg fully illuminated. I should add that I spend 90% of my time deep sky observing.
Secondary - 3.1 or 3.5?
Started by pwp818, 05/02/2007 06:39PM
Posted 05/02/2007 06:39PM
Opening Post
Posted 05/02/2007 07:33PM
#1
Hello:
I vote for a 3.5". The increase in central obstruction is negligable, and people seem to worry about it too much. With a 3.5" secondary, your central obstruction (in percent) will be less than HST. The larger secondary gets you a wider fully illuminated field, and you won't be using as much of the edge of the mirror which can be bad.
Cheers
Mike
Who has a 10" mirror with a 5" secondary
I vote for a 3.5". The increase in central obstruction is negligable, and people seem to worry about it too much. With a 3.5" secondary, your central obstruction (in percent) will be less than HST. The larger secondary gets you a wider fully illuminated field, and you won't be using as much of the edge of the mirror which can be bad.
Cheers
Mike
Who has a 10" mirror with a 5" secondary
Posted 05/02/2007 09:04PM
| Edited 05/02/2007 09:07PM
#2
By going to the 3.5" you nearly triple the fully illuminated area at 100% from .22 to .635°.
If it were a 15" I would go with the 3.1" but with the 16" I think I would go the 3.5". though it would probably not be very apparent at the EP.
If it were a 15" I would go with the 3.1" but with the 16" I think I would go the 3.5". though it would probably not be very apparent at the EP.
[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue
Amateur Imager
Posted 05/02/2007 10:21PM
#3
Hi:
I don't think one can say without knowing a bit more. Focuser height is important here as is the desired use for the scope.
I have been playing around with a 16 inch F/4.42 as I just finished it and will eventually move to a smaller secondary, currently the secondary is a full 4 incher.
For my scope with a 3 inch minimum focuser height and 18 inch inside ring diameter, the numbers looked similar to Floyd's. Since my scope is primarily a DSO scope the larger illuminated field of view will be my choice. When I see a reasonably priced 3.5 inch secondary pop up, I will snag it, till then the 4 incher is fine.
Jon
I don't think one can say without knowing a bit more. Focuser height is important here as is the desired use for the scope.
I have been playing around with a 16 inch F/4.42 as I just finished it and will eventually move to a smaller secondary, currently the secondary is a full 4 incher.
For my scope with a 3 inch minimum focuser height and 18 inch inside ring diameter, the numbers looked similar to Floyd's. Since my scope is primarily a DSO scope the larger illuminated field of view will be my choice. When I see a reasonably priced 3.5 inch secondary pop up, I will snag it, till then the 4 incher is fine.
Jon
Funding Member