Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Seeking advice on 17.5" Dob

Started by paultheengineer, 01/10/2006 12:50AM
Posted 01/10/2006 12:50AM Opening Post
I bought 17.5" optics in 1984 and I remember paying $695 delivered from Coulter. I still have them new, untouched and in the shipping box. Marriage and children caused me to put off building the scope to house my big optics.

In 1982 I built a Plain Jane Dobsonian with Meade Optics, 8", f/7. It is plain, ugly and simple but has served really well over the years when I have drug it out of the basement. That little plywood and Sonotube scope is the extent of my telescope building experience. It has a sink drain pipe for the focuser tube and split cedar shingles and a chunk of closet pole for a spider.

Now I want to build (or buy) a scope to house the 17.5" optics and finally start to enjoy them.

What can you all offer as advice on what I should build or buy?

Thanks,

Paul
Posted 01/10/2006 01:09AM | Edited 01/10/2006 01:12AM #1
Hi Paul,
That is a large scope and will require a bit of building with the mirror cells and everything. You might price the scope from a few builders and then the price of materials and make a decision based on cost, availability and sweat equity.
One sponsor, Astro Sky has this price
17.5" Cost = $1675.00 shipping = $225.00 delivery = 4 to 5 months


[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/10/2006 02:30AM #2
Floyd's advice is very good. I would only add that there are a number of kits on the market as well that might form a compromise between cost and sweat equity. There are links to some of them from rfroyce.com also see tscope and Dob parts.
Posted 01/10/2006 05:20PM #3
OK, thanks to all for great advice.

I am getting the book for sure. All I have is an old publication called "How To Build A Dobsonian Telescope" which is reprints from old Telescope Making Magazine articles. It's really very basic, although I used it to do the job on my little 8" f/7 Dob many years ago. It has a great article about John Dobson and his school bus and his Psychedelic Giraffe scope. LOL!

I agree that my early Coulter mirror is probably sub par. I have read a few things on the net that suggest Coulter mirrors were all 1/2 wave at best in those days. Therefore, I'm not sure it makes sense to get all worked up on building a complex design to hold them. The term "Light Bucket" seems more appropriate.

I have the power tools mentioned (with exception of the router) and I am quite handy in my workshop.

Well, maybe I'm a caveman or just haven't been acclimated to modern Dobsonian design advances but... I should be able to build this thing in the old school style for about $1,000, no?

-Few sheets of plywood and a few plywood rounds ~ $150
-20", 7 foot piece of Sonotube ~ $75 maybe?
-Materials to build a wooden and car seat belt, tailgate style, mirror cell and mirror storage box ~ $25
-Materials for a homemade spider ~ $25
-Teflon, Formica, nuts and bolts ~ $25
-Materials for a draw tube focuser ~ $25
-I have 4 Paul Rini eyepieces that I bought from him in 1998 ~ $70
-I have the Coulter 17.5" mirror set I bought in 1984 ~ $695
-A sturdy hand truck from Home Depot to move the whole thing around ~ $35
-Chiropractics ~ $unknown? 8)

Grand total ~ $1125 of which $765 was sunk years ago. This leaves my current out of pocket at $360 or so. We have two Girl Scout Troops here and I think a light bucket could come in real handy for introducing many young kids to the night sky.

Crazy or doable? I think it will be the most fun I could have for $360.
Posted 01/13/2006 04:31PM #4
Hmmm,

Upon removing the mirror I see it is not Meade, its Parks.



In 1982 I built a Plain Jane Dobsonian with Meade Optics, 8", f/7.