Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Thermal considerations for tube lining or flocking

Started by [email protected], 07/23/2005 09:34AM
Posted 07/23/2005 09:34AM Opening Post
Hello:
I've heard various opinions regarding tube and tube lining materials, specifically whether it's better to have a thermally conductive or insulating tube material. I've read that some people have lined their tube with stuff like cork to have the inner wall be an insulator.
My situation is as follows. I'm making a tube for a 12.5" cassegrain. It will be 1/16" thick aluminum, mainly since it's easier and more practical to get a sheet of aluminum and roll it versus learning how to fiberglass on a limited amount of spare time. I was just going to paint the inside of the tube black to reduce stray light. Unlike a Newtonian where part of the tube is in the field of view of the eyepiece, in a Cassegrain there is no part of the tube that can be seen from the eyepiece so it's not worth spending a lot of time (IMHO) getting the inside of the tube really black.
So, have people actually done experiments to see if it makes a difference to have conductive or insulating tube materials, or is this mostly based on hearsay? What are the arguments in favor for or against using thermally conductive or insulating tube materials? It seems like the arguments would be based on which material would minimize tube currents. With my scope, I think the limiting factor for the effect of tube currents will be the mirror itself. As it is nearly 2.5" thick, it'll take a LONG time for it to cool down (I'm planning on using a few fans to speed things along).

Cheers
Mike Connelley
Posted 07/23/2005 09:42PM | Edited 07/24/2005 03:04AM #1
My two cents...

Any experiments regarding insulative & conductive scope interiors would need to be standardized & controlled. With so many factors contributing to a particular scope's thermal "performance," it's easy to see how one or more aspects of the scope's design & construction might override the "interior composition" part of the equation. Significant considerations include: primary mass/thickness, cell design/mass, primary baffle design/mass, secondary assembly design/mass (including spider), baseline temps, etc.).

In the case of a classical or other open-tubed cassegrain, I would think an insulative interior might be more appropriate with a 1/16th-inch aluminum tube structure. Still, the practical contribution (insulative vs. conductive) may remain relatively insignificant. If you go with an insulative interior, consider a concrete form tube (i.e. Qwik-tube/Sonotube). I think they make much more sense than cork sheet -- much easier to implement (already tubular!), cheaper, and more durable.

Hmmm...how about a Qwik-tube interior surrounded by an intermediate air space (say, 1/8th-inch)?

Yes, the rear end (primary & cell/housing) should receive much of your design consideration. More mass => more heat.

I agree about the "blackness" of the interior: with proper baffling -- including the front end, ahead of the secondary -- even an aluminized interior (egad! 8O ) won't generate stray light at the image plane.

Cheers & best wishes.
-Dan
Posted 07/24/2005 12:26AM | Edited 07/24/2005 11:55AM #2
Up here in the northern U.S. where temperatures often drop at night and dewing can be a problem, a painted aluminum tube for a 6" f/8 caused problems. It radiated too well, and the secondary almost always dewed up. On some nights the primary dewed up.

A layer of cork solved the problem. A friend has had good luck with unpainted aluminum (a poor radiator) with a lining of flocking paper.

Clear skies, Alan