Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Tools: Bench bandsaw vs. bench scroll saw

Started by samg74, 01/15/2004 02:10AM
Posted 01/15/2004 02:10AM Opening Post
For those of us who really want to get away cheap. You know. The White Castle end of the ATM community....

What's to choose between a cheap little bench bandsaw and a decent bench scroll saw ?

A 9"/10" bandsaw or a decent 18"/22" scroll saw will both cost under $200 with shipping. Wood gets cut either way.

I've used good bandsaws in the 16"/18" sizes. Nice stuff, but they carry wider blades and have to more stable.

The bench scroll saw has to give smoother results than my old hand scroll saw. It just died, so I'm in the market for a replacement. (No, not a coping saw.)

Thanks, guys !
Posted 01/15/2004 05:18PM #1
As others have noted, you would be better off with a bandsaw in the $200 range. You would be surprised how much better you can do by hand (with a bit of practice) than some of the $200 scroll saws on the market. The cheapest scroll saw worth getting is the Dewalt 788, and that is $400. It is a fine machine: quiet, heavy, and little vibration when properly bolted down. I had a $199 ($99 now that the "variable speed" model is out) Delta and got tired of the noise and trying to force it to do the work of a bandsaw.

A bandsaw is much more versatile (except for inside cuts, of course). Set up a few small extension tables, you can rip wide boards. Set up a fence, you can resaw boards to a desired thickness. You could even use it to plane a rough board flat with a little ingenuity. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses, decide what you need to do most.