Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Truss Material. Aluminum bar??

Started by SteveMD, 11/06/2003 05:18PM
Posted 11/06/2003 05:18PM Opening Post
Hi there, first post, long time hobbyist, first time ATMer!

I am planning on building a 12.5" F/5ish truss dob and want to do something different for the trusses.

I want to use the traditional 8 truss design but would like your opinion on using 1/4"x1" aluminum strips for the top and bottom 4 and 1/4"x1.5" strips for the sides (wider to resist the gravitational forces at low altitudes).

Since I am using strips and not a tube or angle, I'm wondering how this would work. I have a nice method of mounting the strips that I think will look really nice but need to know if strips/bars/whatever you call them will be a feasible solution optically.

Thanks
Steve in MD
Posted 11/06/2003 05:57PM #1
Steve, I believe most would agree that flat bar stock as you
mention would be totally unacceptable in anything but very short ie...3-6" pieces as far as stiffness is concerned, and this is what one is looking for to keep the scope in collimation...

JMHO

Preston
Posted 11/06/2003 06:05PM #2
I think it's an issue of physics rather than optics. Tubes, by design, are equally resistant to bending forces in all directions. Angle isn't exactly so, but is strong enough so it doesn't matter.

Although I haven't tried aluminum bar stock for trusses, my experience with it elsewhere (mostly on boats) suggests that it simply isn't a good choice: too bendy, or (if you make it strong enough) too heavy. Take that same mass and put it into a tube and the strength goes up an enormous amount (just ask the makers of Cannondale bikes).

Obviously it'll be strong as heck in the long axis... but unless you have extremely good mounting you'd be subject to torsion (in which it won't be taht strong) or bends in the short axis.

Of course, if you design it right it technically wouldn't matter since everything's theoretically in direct tension or compression--the wonders of triangles. Still, "in theory, theory and practice are the same. in practice, taht is rarely the case". Given the wide range of tubes and angles available, I'd wonder why you'd bother.

Not incidentally, you could acheive a similar look by using an aluminum I beam cut lengthwise down the "I". You'd get two "T" strips per I beam. If you grind the T flange down a lot, it's still MUCH stronger than a flat strip but you can put the flange on the inside where it won't show. Grinding the T off entirely at the top and bottom make it possible to moung but don't affect the overall strength taht much. It'll look like flat strips from the outside but work like angle stock.

Posted 11/06/2003 08:49PM #3
Thanks everyone. Back to the drawing board (literally) smile
Posted 11/07/2003 06:29PM #4
Steve,

Using .75" Dia, .049" Wall 6061 Aluminum tubing will work fine for a 12.5" f/5. Here is a link to the one I just finished...

http://www.astromart.com/messages.asp?message_id=99307&page=

Let me know if you need any help.
-Glenn

[email protected]