Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Truss or tube?

Started by bstratton, 04/13/2003 06:56PM
Posted 04/13/2003 06:56PM Opening Post
Hello all, any advice appreciated. I have talked to a few already about this. I have a 10" f/8 mirror (which is a pretty long focal length), and a Univ. Opt. mirror cell. I was originally planning to make them into a truss scope. However, lately I have been thinking that a conventional tube dobsonian setup might be better for easier use, as I could just take the tube and put it on top of the mount cradle and start to observe, without having to fuss with the tubes, and collimation, ect. I have a minivan, so the long tube should fit in my vehicle, as I will need to travel most of the time to use.

I originally thought of building the truss scope so I would have better handling of thermal currents, and the mirror would cool down better. But with the tube I heard that the observers heat does not drift into the telescopes light path, and also helps with dewing, and extranneous bright light sources in vicinity. I also think it will be much easier for me to make a tube scope, as my wood working skills, equipment are limited.

Any recommendations? Anyone been in the same situation? Which did you do, and what were the results? Are the thermal currents in a tube scope that big of a deal with a fan at the back of the fairly open Univ. Opt. mirror cell? How about a 14" tube instead of the standard 12" tube for this mirror? I know the larger tube will be more cumbersome, and your sec. mirror may have to be larger (I have a 1.83" minor axis), but will the thermal currents be reduced significantly?

Thanks,

Brien Stratton
Posted 04/13/2003 08:51PM #1
My instincts would side with your current lean toward a tube. But, you should probably look at Bob Royce's sight rfroyce.com. His personal scope is a 10" f/8 newtonian, and he went the other way--started with a tube and went to a truss. I think that it is in the personal scopes and musings section.
Posted 04/14/2003 03:46PM #2
I got a 10" f9.6 mirror that I made into a scope last year. I guess a tube would be nice, but I couldn't figure out how I would transport it anywhere. Anyway, I made a VERY simple truss design (1x2 trusses) that works for me.

My next project for this scope will be to angle the secondary by 22.5 degrees (instead of 45) so that the focuser is angled towards the ground. I have seen scopes like that on this forum and they look much more convenient. You might think about doing that so you wouldn't need a ladder with your scope.

Charlie

Fort Lewis Observatory: (37.238, -108.052) ~2360m (7744 ft.) elevation.
Darkness - typically 6.5+
Scope - Meade 16" LX200; f6.3 focal reducer
Focus - JMI Smart focus
Camera - SBIG ST-10XE; (~.5"/pixel)
Guiding - AO-8 and/or Meade 5"/DSI/PHD
http://www.fortlewis.edu/observatory
Posted 04/14/2003 06:19PM #3
For a 10" scope I think a solid tube would be preferable, though f/8 is very long and cumbersome. I've owned 10" f/5.6 and 14" f/4.5 solid tube scopes and have been very happy with them, never any dew problems, easy to set up though quite an effort to lift and carry. I've never owned a truss scope so can't claim to be an authority.

About a year ago I sawed my 14" Sonotube in half, attached some aluminum bars, resulting in a much more portable scope that snaps together in seconds, doesn't need alignment, and is simpler and cheaper than a truss. I think most scopes in the range of about 10 to 16 inches will be built this way in the future. There is some more discussion of this in the Dobsonians forum.

Attached Image:

jacobson's attachment for post 66501