Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Vladimir please check this out.

Started by EL Jones, 04/18/2004 01:38PM
Posted 04/18/2004 01:38PM Opening Post
Vladimir, what do you think of the performance of this Newtonian? It has astigmatism slighlty less than half the coma of an equivalent parabola but is that good enough? The obstruction is .24.
Ed Jones

Attached Image:

EL Jones's attachment for post 15100
Posted 04/18/2004 10:37PM #1
Ed, assuming these are spots for the best image plane, the blur (some coma, but astigmatism is clearly dominant) in the green light is about 30 microns 0.25 degree off axis. Tangential coma (full blur length) in an f/5 paraboloid would be about 41 microns, or nearly 40% larger. This far off-axis this configuration is inferior to the parabola, due to astigmatic blur being about 2.6 times smaller than tangential coma for nearly identical level of the RMS wavefront error. The astigmatic blur at 0.25 degrees off-axis is about 4.5 times larger than the Airy disc. For the diffraction limited level, it needs to be 0.6 times the Airy disc diameter, which sets diffraction limited field radius of the configuration at nearly 0.1 degree astigmatism-wise. This is about 50% wider than the parabola, whose diffraction limited field radius would be 0.064 degrees.

Farther off-axis it falls further behind the parabola, since both astigmatism and lateral color (originating from the sub-aperture corrector), increase with the square of off-axis distance.

If the corrector is a Jones-Bird variety, or at least have the same sign astigmatism, it might be considerably better than that for the visual use, since good part of astigmatism would be cancelled by the opposite astigmatism of the eyepiece, as long as you'd use ordinary (no-Nagler-type) eyepeices.