Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

YASQ (Yet another Secondary Question)

Started by toml, 10/01/2003 03:33PM
Posted 10/01/2003 03:33PM Opening Post
Lost in the long thread below, Vlad and Mike and Newt helped me conclude that somewhere between 2.3 and 2.7 min axis for my secondary was appropriate:

"If you'd take H=0.25"+1.45"+1.5"=3.2", then your diagonal-to-focus distance would be L=T/2+H=7"+3.2"=10.2". Your min diagonal minor axis is A=L/f#=10.2"/4.46=2.3". For 0.5" (~0.5 degree here) fully illuminated field you'd need
A=2.3"+0.5"(1-L/F)= 2.7" minor axis. Illumination 14mm
off-axis is 82%, and 63% 23mm off-axis. Not much different from what you came up with. Take your pick. "

Well, I did take my pick. It took me a couple days to think through this analysis, but I see it is all correct now. One thing though, is this is all theory. In practice one doesn't find an infinite choice of secondaries. And I found at my local astronomy shop a really nice holder and spider set up for a 2.55" secondary (which they also supply). A quick calculation at the shop showed that this was a 19.5% CO by diameter which is good in my books, not too little going on some wild planetary optimization goose chase, not too much as to turn my newt into a low-contrast SCT with diffraction spikes.

So in the real world I found and bought this nice, light totally suitable for my build 2.55" holder and mirror. So now I know that fits in that range Vlad (and Mike and Newt) helped calculate. But seeing Vlad's response to John Bambury one thread below made me wonder if 2.55 is close to my theoretical minium of 2.3 I don't want to see the edges of the diagonal (of course you could paint or tape them over as a last resort), but right now I have a freedom which John doesn't: I am designing and can make my cage diameter anything I want, whereas he is stuck with his tube as is.

I can also position my cage vertically anwhere. So, Vlad, Mike or anyone else care to give me a yea or nay on this one:
Given a 13.1" D and FL of 58.5" f/4.46 and diagonal (real) of 2.55" and focuser hole of 2"

what should be my ID of my upper cage assuming that I am not doing any secondary offset, just a centered secondary. I was thinking 14" with a .25" focuser board. Still sound good? I was also thinking of making a 1/4" filter slide with the one 2" hole being filter free which would be on the inside of the ID and could act as a baffle if that is a consideration?

Thank you (all) !!!! You're so helpful!

Tom L
Posted 10/01/2003 04:54PM #1
Well, Tom, I would think that 14 or even 15 inches would be fine. I own a homemade 13.1" f/4.5 dob (fl=58.7 inches). I use a 2.6" MA secondary in a Novak holder which reduces the MA a little, and a Moonlite Crayford focuser. All mounted in/on a 16" ID (solid, not truss) tube. Even at that size, I have fully and 75% illuminated field diameters of 0.44 and 1.58 inches (0.44/1.55 degrees) respectively, numbers from NEWT. Visually, the scope works wonderfully. So, you could probably go up to 15" to allow room for your filter slide and still be OK.

Just my $.02
Doug Scobel
Posted 10/01/2003 04:59PM #2
I have the 2.6" diag in a 15" Truss-tube DOB and it workd just fine at 17% obstruction. The secondary is 16.375" in diameter which is normal for a 15".
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 10/02/2003 03:05AM #3
Tom, I'd worry about the upper cage diameter in regard to thermal issue more than in regard to potentil vignetting. If you'd have a circular 13.1 stop at the front opening, it would cause 10% wignetting 24mm off-axis. Unlike vignetting by the focuser bottom, which kicks in only when it gets larger than that at the diagonal, vignetting at the front opening adds to that at the diagonal; so, if vignetting at the diagonal is 40% 24mm off-axis, the total vignetting would be 40%+10%=50% - not a big difference (BTW, such stop would help you get rid of most of primary's off-axis astigmatism, which would probably be more of a plus for the edge definition ).

More important is to have any thermally unstable surface farther away from the incoming bundles forming your high-quality field. That would be a reason not to go bellow 14" ID. Somewhat more wouldn't hurt either.

A 2.55" sounds a bit too tight, although it wouldn't have the very edge area "participating" in forming scope's diffraction limited field (which is here less than 2mm in diameter). But, like you said, that's the closest you could get, and that should work well too (even if you go for 14.5" ID, to accomodate the filter slide).