First, I am currently rebuilding my 6 inch F9 reflector. It is a homemade wooden square truss tube dob design. It weighs a ton and according to newt, the "tube" is too small. It has a 1 1/4 or 1.3 inch secondary in it. I am thinking that I would get better performance if I were to drop down to a 1 inch secondary. It also appears to me that you can go back and forth if you choose to do so. I dont see any dimensional differences (according to newt) because of changing the size of your sencondary. Is this correct and am I better off with a smaller secondary? Next.....is the proper size of your mirror (for newt and otherwise) edge to edge NOT counting the champher? In other words, my mirror I believe is really a 5 and 7/8 mirror as opposed to a 6 inch even tho its 6 inches across it if you include the champher. I am going with a sonotube design. I have made a low profile 2 inch 2 speed crayford focuser, a secondary mirror holder and a mirror cell so far. Almost got the spider finished. No tube rings or mount (which I havent decided on yet)started just yet. Any suggestions are welcome. I am also going to make a reflex sight for it. Yep, I just like making things and I have a whole shop at my disposal to do so.
One thing I dont really know about is how good my mirror really is. It is in need of recoating but it still does OK as near as I can tell. I have also made myself a sight tube and a laser collimator, a true blessing to have for a newb. 8) Now, the last thing, I found the article about making a copy scope and that is very interseting to me. I found a copier today that the place was more than glad for me to take off their hands. Unfortunately, It didnt have the lense inside I was hoping to find. Its more like a 1 and a quarter inch double lense set about the same distance apart in a cell. Looked like it had a redish tint to it. Looked like I might be able to take it apart and use one of them for the reflex sight possibly. There were also many goodies that I took from it. A good stepper motor and lots of gears and some other things I snagged from it. So what kind of copier am I looking for to get the correct lense from for this task? I have about a blue million more questions but they can wait. Im trying to find someone close to me that has some experiance to help me out but that is difficult at best and there isnt any clubs that are really close to me. (Edinburgh,Indiana about 30 mi south of Indy) IAS is prolly the closest to me and I hope to make it there soon but thats still a bit of a drive for me. My apologies for the almost book and thanks of you read this far.
A few questions from a lost soul.
Started by Kevin_KYLE, 07/12/2006 11:49PM
Posted 07/12/2006 11:49PM
Opening Post
Posted 07/12/2006 11:59PM
#1
Hi Kevin:
A couple of thoughts...
From what you say, the correct measurement for your mirror is 5 and 7/8 inches...
As far as the secondary size goes, it is easily changed but the differences between a 1 inch and a 1.25 inch are subtle at best... Both will give good planetary images but may vignette the image with a widefield eyepiece...
As far as the copy scope lens goes, I believe these are available from various surplus sites and I guess if your expections are not high these can provide nice images...
jon
A couple of thoughts...
From what you say, the correct measurement for your mirror is 5 and 7/8 inches...
As far as the secondary size goes, it is easily changed but the differences between a 1 inch and a 1.25 inch are subtle at best... Both will give good planetary images but may vignette the image with a widefield eyepiece...
As far as the copy scope lens goes, I believe these are available from various surplus sites and I guess if your expections are not high these can provide nice images...
jon
Posted 07/13/2006 05:50AM
#2
Kevin:
I wouldn't waste my time on the copyscope. I got a big ole 80mm lens from the Surplus Shed (4# of glass & alum.) and have gone through several permutations and all I have to show for are a lot of PVC & CPVC parts and pieces.
These lenes have a rather short FL and make for a very stubby and in my case a rather heavy piece to perch on even a good camera tripod.
If you are looking to build a scope then look in the Sheds objective lens section. They have a couple of nice 80mm air spaced doublets, fully coated and in plastic cells. One of the lenes has an FL of 400mm and the other is 900mm. These would make a much better scope for about the same cash outlay.
Just the ramblings of of an old retired GI.
Be carefull out there.
I wouldn't waste my time on the copyscope. I got a big ole 80mm lens from the Surplus Shed (4# of glass & alum.) and have gone through several permutations and all I have to show for are a lot of PVC & CPVC parts and pieces.
These lenes have a rather short FL and make for a very stubby and in my case a rather heavy piece to perch on even a good camera tripod.
If you are looking to build a scope then look in the Sheds objective lens section. They have a couple of nice 80mm air spaced doublets, fully coated and in plastic cells. One of the lenes has an FL of 400mm and the other is 900mm. These would make a much better scope for about the same cash outlay.
Just the ramblings of of an old retired GI.
Be carefull out there.
The "star" we look at tonight may have exploded millenniums ago. (To progress, we must discern what exists and what does not).
Posted 07/13/2006 07:18AM
#3
Since you've got a 2" focuser, you might stick with the
1.3" diagonal. It will give you a little more illumination
with 2" eyepieces. But the difference will be small.
Copy scopes tend to be very heavy for their aperture.
As someone already suggested, you might just get an
achromat.
1.3" diagonal. It will give you a little more illumination
with 2" eyepieces. But the difference will be small.
Copy scopes tend to be very heavy for their aperture.
As someone already suggested, you might just get an
achromat.
Funding Member