Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Aperture and Seeing Conditions

Started by mte1955, 04/20/2009 01:00PM
Posted 04/20/2009 01:00PM Opening Post
Can anyone explain why large aperture telescopes are so sensitive to the prevailing seeing conditions? I was at a recent star party and Saturn actually looked better through the smaller telescopes even though the sky seemed transparent.
Posted 04/20/2009 02:03PM | Edited 04/20/2009 02:04PM #1
Michael Tencza said:

Can anyone explain why large aperture telescopes are so sensitive to the prevailing seeing conditions? I was at a recent star party and Saturn actually looked better through the smaller telescopes even though the sky seemed transparent.

First, keep in mind that transparency and seeing are two different animals. Transparency is a measure of how clear the sky is. Seeing is a measure of how "steady" the sky is. You can have very clear skies and turbulent, unsteady views of the planets. You can also have very hazy skies and very steady, detailed views of the planets - a night of good seeing.

Aperture determines potential resolution, and larger telescopes are capable of seeing finer detail. This also means that seeing more often limits the capabilities of larger scopes. While a quality 4" telescope may be able to perform to its ability on many nights, a 10" telescope might be limited by the steadiness of the air.

You have to be careful because there are other issues that can impede the performance of larger instruments. Their optics have more mass and hold more heat, so it takes them longer to cool down. On nights of dropping temperatures large telescopes are often playing catch up. Active cooling methods can help.

In my experience here in the northeastern U.S., at least in the 3.5" to 10" range, a larger telescope always seems to hold some advantage for planetary viewing. With patience the larger always shows moments to minutes where it reveals more detail. In addition, when using the same magnifications, a larger instrument provides a larger exit pupil, reducing the effect of floaters, and provides better color rendition.

I did an experiment with my wife's 14.5" f/6 equatorial on several nights when Saturn and Jupiter were well placed, using it with a 6.5" off-axis mask and at full aperture. While I was certainly not seeing all the detail a 14.5" would be capable of showing at full aperture, the views were always better than they were with the off-axis mask. The mask went in the trash.

Clear skies, Alan
Posted 04/21/2009 05:41PM | Edited 04/21/2009 05:42PM #2
Excellent discussion guys. I should have given more information, but things often get left out when posting like this. Here are some of the details.

The sky was very clear, but the atmosphere in our area is not ideal (Jordan Lake, NC). The more experienced club members told me that the viewing in Florida is often much better if that helps anyone.

Many of us arrived before nightfall and setup before dark which gave us roughly 90 minutes of thermal equilibration time. BTW it was great to see Mercury for the first time, just over the trees early in the evening.

Back to the topic. When it became pretty dark out I took a look at Saturn to compare the view to what I normally see from my front yard. It was very beautiful and defined and I told everyone around to look for themselves.

Eventually we began swapping scopes and eyepieces to compare them. One was a 14.5" Starsplitter. The owner is very experienced and always collimates the scope before using it. Anyway, while there were moments of good seeing at the eyepiece in this scope, the image vascillated and that made it hard to view. The smaller scopes did not show this, surely for the reasons all of you mentioned, and were easier use for Saturn. I understand the Starsplitter is a great telescope and your explanations jive with what I saw. I only asked the question because I am interested in a larger aperture telescope than what I have now and want to know what to expect from it.
Posted 04/26/2009 12:38PM #3
Follow up to the original post: Same site, one week later.

Saturn was great up to about 300x and even beyond in a 14.5" Starmaster, so it was indeed turbulent atmosphere that we had one week ago.

BTW this time one of our club members brought out a complete line of Ethos eyepieces (plural=Etha?) and my vote as well as everyones else's there goes with Uncle Al. These occulars are simply a remarkable achievement and just plain fun to use.