Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

The worst question we ask of beginners...

Started by Zhimbo, 07/29/2006 12:07AM
Posted 07/29/2006 12:07AM Opening Post
I'm not sure if the "Beginner's Forum" is the best place for this or not, but here goes:

There's a question I regularly see asked of beginners looking to buy their first scope. It's some variation of this:

"What kind of observing do you want to do?"
or
"What are you most interested in?"

Now, the question has merit. I see where it's coming from.

But who among us, as beginners, had well-informed and decisive ideas about what kind of observing we would like best, BEFORE we've put in observing time? Even if we've looked through a few scopes a few times?

Most of the time I see this question asked, I'm pretty sure some newbie on the other end of the internet is sitting there with a deer-in-headlights look in their eyes.

While we should ask Who is using the scope (how old? especially), and Where they'll be using it (at home in the country; local park; city balcony?), shouldn't we assume that any newbie should be getting a good all-around scope, instead of something specialized for a type of viewing that they may well change their minds about after a few times under the stars?
Posted 07/29/2006 02:20AM #1
Jim Nelson said:

I'm not sure if the "Beginner's Forum" is the best place for this or not, but here goes:

There's a question I regularly see asked of beginners looking to buy their first scope. It's some variation of this:

"What kind of observing do you want to do?"
or
"What are you most interested in?"

Now, the question has merit. I see where it's coming from.

But who among us, as beginners, had well-informed and decisive ideas about what kind of observing we would like best, BEFORE we've put in observing time? Even if we've looked through a few scopes a few times?

Most of the time I see this question asked, I'm pretty sure some newbie on the other end of the internet is sitting there with a deer-in-headlights look in their eyes.

While we should ask Who is using the scope (how old? especially), and Where they'll be using it (at home in the country; local park; city balcony?), shouldn't we assume that any newbie should be getting a good all-around scope, instead of something specialized for a type of viewing that they may well change their minds about after a few times under the stars?

Jim, you are, of course, correct.

However, I think that the question is essentially rhetorical, meaning, "What the best scope, mount, eyepiece, or locationis depends upon the specicifics of different kinds of observing."

The best answer that we tend to give is, "Go to star parties and find out what interests you before you start shelling out a lot of money, or even a little money." This could be argued to be similar to the quotation above.

My comments are not meant as dissagreement.

Lorne Johnson
Posted 07/29/2006 10:41AM #2
Hello to everyone:

First before I comment on the question at hand, I do think this thread has all the makings of "beating a dead horse." So, please, let us listen to what each of us says carefully and let it go at that. If this starts to bog down then I will step in.


>>>"What kind of observing do you want to do?"
or
"What are you most interested in?"

Now, the question has merit. I see where it's coming from.

But who among us, as beginners, had well-informed and decisive ideas about what kind of observing we would like best, BEFORE we've put in observing time? Even if we've looked through a few scopes a few times?
-------
-------

I have asked this very question many times over the years and I think there are very good reasons for a simple basic question like this.

Sometimes first timers do have very specific interests and goals. Whether I think these goals are the wisest path to a long career as an astronut, it is important to know the motivations and what has excited them. This is really what this question is about, finding out what the motivation is...

It also is a question that allows one to access someone's level of understanding about not only telescopes but astronomy in general...

>>>While we should ask Who is using the scope (how old? especially), and Where they'll be using it (at home in the country; local park; city balcony?), shouldn't we assume that any newbie should be getting a good all-around scope, instead of something specialized for a type of viewing that they may well change their minds about after a few times under the stars...
====

The great thing about forums like this is that they allow us to relate on an individual basis with each other, a first timer can come and get some advice about not only which telescope to choose but about amateur astronomy in general.

So making any general assumption like "a good all around scope" is a mistake until we have a better idea about exactly who they are and indeed what their motivations are. It may be true that for the individual asking the question, a "good all around scope" is the best choice but that is certainly not always the case.

And in any event, the path so that someone understands the reasons why a "good all around scope" might be best can be quite different depending on their motivations and what it is that did excite them.

(I also have been around long enough to know that not only is there no such thing as a "good all around scope" but also that everyone has a different opinion as to what constitutes a "good all around scope.")

Imagine two different anwswers to "What are you most interested in?"

1. "I am very interested in looking at the moon and also watch the birds in my back yard."

2. "I recently looked at some hubble pictures of the Ring-tailed galaxy and was excited by the beautiful colors. I want to see those colors for myself..."

Clearly the first question would require some specific answers, the second some basic background and explanations...

So, the way I look at it, I cannot make assumptions or make suggestions until I know more about the person and his/her motivations. And I think one of the best ways to find that out is simply ask a basic "ice breaker" that engages them and allows them to share a bit about themselves.

Books and websites can suggest "the six inch DOB" as the best all around beginners scope but we have the advantage that we can first learn about the person, make friends with them if you will, and then try to help them.

Helping them might mean validating their wishes and goals and providing some concrete suggestions or it might mean trying to steer them in a different direction...

So, I suggest that behind a simple question like "what are you most interested in?" there is more than meets the eye and we need to take this more slowly than just jumping to the conclusion that everyone is like many of us, ie just stumbled on to something aimlessly and it turned to a passion.

Best wishes, clear skies

Jon Isaacs