Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Is the visual deep-sky observer an endangered spec

Started by Inge_S, 02/15/2012 01:40PM
Posted 02/15/2012 01:40PM Opening Post
Some years ago there was a lot of activity on this forum. During the last years the activity has dropped to near zero. I sometimes wonder what the reason for this can be.
Have the active people found other, more interesting forums or blogs?
Have people started doing imaging instead of observing through the eyepiece?

Some time ago I tried to make some posts about previous observations of various objects (some showpieces and some less known objects), but the response was very low and few people read the posts.

Do anyone have any good ideas what can be done to get some more activity here?
Posted 02/15/2012 03:26PM | Edited 02/15/2012 04:17PM #1
You ask an important question, one I'm sure the owners of this web site are asking themselves. Perhaps the place for astronomy discussions is moving away from forums like AMart to different media? Our local astronomy club was introduced to a group of college-age kids that were all engaged in astronomy, visual and imaging. They essentially had a "club", but it was virtual, nearly all communication was done on smartphones and social media sites. I also got the impression that they had little interest in hanging out with our group of mostly older folks and coming to our monthly meetings.

Jim McSheehy
Posted 02/15/2012 06:39PM #2
Inge Skauvik said:

Some years ago there was a lot of activity on this forum. During the last years the activity has dropped to near zero. I sometimes wonder what the reason for this can be.
Have the active people found other, more interesting forums or blogs?
Have people started doing imaging instead of observing through the eyepiece?

Some time ago I tried to make some posts about previous observations of various objects (some showpieces and some less known objects), but the response was very low and few people read the posts.

Do anyone have any good ideas what can be done to get some more activity here?

Don't know about "endangered", but its definitely not dead, for sure smile

I'm a visual-only DSO observer myself - from Day-1, with no interest whatsoever in photography aspects of the hobby. From what I can tell, there's a bit of demographic preferences at play with respect to what may appear to be low responses and / or absenteeism. Not in the least is the fact that us visual-only folks tend to be loners, really - without the (what seems like) burning need to "show and tell" like the photography bunch.

I myself do not attend star parties (as much as you can call them that here in the UK cwy ),and don't do outreach. I prefer to head out and enjoy using my scope hoping really only to create lasting impressions of what I've observed..,

Keep posting - rest assured, at least you know some of us are reading grin

Regards,

S Roberts
Posted 02/15/2012 08:52PM #3
Me too Im more of a visual kind of guy have a cam but really prefer to look through the eyepiece, but only started about 3 or so years ago still learning the night sky grin
Pete
Posted 02/15/2012 11:34PM #4
I read almost all of the deep sky posts here at AM and also at Cloudy Nights. However, I rarely reply unless I can be of help on some issue.

CN definitely has more traffic and some very experienced observers which I like to follow.

I tend to enjoy the quick posts on a single object, such as "Can anyone help me with ...?" Or "I finally spotted ...". A recent post on CN I enjoyed was the question on how people's interests in deep sky have changed over the years.

The longer logs of 10 or 20 objects viewed with lots of details, these posts for me aren't as interesting to read but are good for reference. If I have a question about some object, then I can use the search engine. I'm currently not good at taking notes or drawing sketches, so I don't post logs myself.

Yes, the number of visual observers is declining, but I think this particular forum has been eclipsed by CN.

Deep sky is by nature non-controversial (unless the Caldwell catalog comes up), which is fine with me. So the volume will be lower than a lot of other topics. The quiet nature of many of us doesn't help either.

Mike
Posted 02/16/2012 06:11AM #5
I joined Astromart because I read about it in Astronomy Hacks. At the time, I didn't even own a telescope but was building one.

Because of the $12 fee, I would not have joined if I had known of the existence of other forums at the time.

Now I also belong to Astronomy Forum (for free!) and I like it a lot since there is a group of about 100 people (all relatively new to amateur astronomy) in a program to view / image / sketch the Messier series.

I keep coming back to AMart since there are posts on this forum that I would never see in the other forum. For example, answers to questions I have asked are much better from Amart members than answers I have received in the other forum.

Besides that, people on Amart have a better sense of humor.

Then, there is the one area where Amart excels -- the classifieds. The Astronomy Forum posts about one ad per week (total for all categories combined) and even that ad is usually pretty lame.

Anyway, to sum up, I did notice when I first joined, that the forums for religion and politics were much more active than any of the others and I found this rather curious. Not that I objected. I just found it curious.

When Amart started a forum on Astrology I knew the end of the world was closer than I had originally anticipated.

Clears,
Joe

In lumine tuo videbimus lumen.

8O Home-made 10” Dob / Home-made 4” refractor

EPs: Konig 32mm (1.25") / Zhumell WF 30mm (2") / Nagler 13mm T1 / Orion Sirius Plossls 25 & 10mm / Zhumell Plossl 9 mm / Meade MA 9mm
Posted 02/16/2012 02:33PM #6
Thank you, guys - I appreciate your response.
I started with astronomy already in the sixties. At that time imaging was for professionals and many amateurs made an excellent job observing variable stars just by comparing brightness by visual comparison with other stars. In the late sixties and early seventies the first amateur images started to appear. To me it seemed to be an activity for the exclusive club of Questar owners, although some people made their first trials with simpler set-ups. Already at an early stage I decided to stick with visual observing. The reason was partly economy, and partly the fact that the Norwegian climate is bad, and I really wanted to use the precious hours with clear sky to view the sky directly through the eyepiece.
The real boost to imaging came, of course, when the photographic film was replaced by photo-sensitive devices. I'm impressed by much of the work done by skilled imagers today. Even with modest equipment it is possible to blow the classical Palomar telecope photos away. But with the advent of the Internet, the easy way to get excellent astro images is just to download the work of people possessing equipment and experience far better than what I can even afford to dream about.
The bottom line - to me there is still nothing comparable with a night under the stars utilising the power of good optics. Even for the visual observer there is some development, both when comes to telescopes, eyepieces, tracking devices and observation guides and comprehensive tables of objects.
I hope that I can contribute to keeping this forum alive. During some periods I had problems limiting myself, also being active on Norwegian, German and even Russian forums.
Besides having an interest in deep-sky observations I'm very fond of double star observation. Therefore I hope that you will forgive me if I sometimes mix up different types of objects in the same post.
Inge S
Posted 02/18/2012 02:21PM #7
Inge Skauvik said:

Some years ago there was a lot of activity on this forum. During the last years the activity has dropped to near zero. I sometimes wonder what the reason for this can be.
Have the active people found other, more interesting forums or blogs?
Have people started doing imaging instead of observing through the eyepiece?

Some time ago I tried to make some posts about previous observations of various objects (some showpieces and some less known objects), but the response was very low and few people read the posts.

Do anyone have any good ideas what can be done to get some more activity here?

I don't know what can be done, but the simple fact is Joe and Jane Amateur have identified Astromart as "the classifieds place" and Cloudy Nights as "the discussion groups place."

;-)

Uncle Rod

Time on your hands?
Waste it with Uncle Rod's Astro Blog!

http://uncle-rods.blogspot.com/