Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

?Best type of scope for planetary viewing?

Started by Mta472, 05/15/2008 02:29PM
Posted 05/15/2008 02:29PM Opening Post
In your opinion, what is the best type of telescope for planetary viewing? I am primarily interested in seeing details of Mars, Saturn and Jupiter. I can not afford an APO refractor and want GOTO capabilities.

Thanks for your recommendations.

Mike


Posted 05/15/2008 02:44PM #1
A 6" or 7" Maksutov-Cassegrain, an 8" long focus (f/8 or greater) optimized Newtonian, a premium Dob with a very high quality fast mirror (a Zambuto for example), or a 6" or larger long focus (f/15 or there abouts) achromatic refractor should each provide excellent planetary views. The MCT is probably the most cost effective choice and will present the least amount of hassle.

I'm not sure why you need go-to if you're primarily interested in the planets, however.

Dave Mitsky

Chance favors the prepared mind.

De gustibus non est disputandum.
Posted 05/15/2008 04:52PM | Edited 05/15/2008 04:53PM #2
As Jean Texereau writes in his "How to Make a Telescope," "The astronomer's hopes are almost wholly tied to the size and quality of the objective." It isn't the type of telescope that is of major importance, it is the aperture and quality of optics that provide the potential for fine planetary views. Over the years I've had fabulous planetary views through apochromats, Newtonians, Dall-Kirkhams, Mak-Newts, and Mak-Casses. The only characteristics they had in common were quality optics, and apertures larger than six inches.

As the former owner of an 8" f/8 Newtonian, and the current owner of a 10" f/9.5, I can attest to their fine performance. However, a well done Newtonian of shorter focal ratio, can work almost as well - close enough that the difference is rather subtle, and adding a little aperture is, IMHO, better than making some monster scope. My wife's 14.5" f/6 outdoes them both. Even when it is seeing challenged, which is usually the case, the brighter view and larger exit pupil (at identical magnifications) are appreciated.

Clear skies, Alan