Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Comet 17P/Holmes on Sunday Night, 2007/10/28

Started by Dave Mitsky, 10/29/2007 08:38AM
Posted 10/29/2007 08:38AM | Edited 10/29/2007 02:10PM Opening Post
I finally saw the spectacular outburst from the periodic comet 17P/Holmes on Saturday night through my 15x70 Burgess Optical binocular. However, before I could set up my 80mm f/5 Orion ShortTube 80 achromat, clouds began to move in from the west. Since the forecast was for clear skies, I went back into my brother's house to watch the end of the half of the disastrous Penn State game and a bit of the World Series. Unfortunately, every time I went outside to check on the conditions it was overcast. When I finally went to bed around 2:00 a.m., it was still cloudy.

It was obvious after looking at the comet from the Naylor Observatory for a period of a couple of hours on Sunday night that the three other "pseudonuclei" (two of which were rather faint) that I could see through the Astronomical Society of Harriburg's 17" f/15 classical Cassegrain at magnifications of 162 (40mm University Optics MK-70), 202 (32mm University Optics Koenig-II), and 259x (25mm University Optics MK-70) were merely field stars. Apparently, the two stars near the true pseduonucleus (is that an oxymoron?) were GSC0333400738 (magnitude 10.9) and GSC0333400788 (magnitude 8.7).

17P/Holmes exhibited a distinct inner and outer coma as well as a fan-shaped area of ejecta extending southwestward from the true pseudonucleus, which appeared distinctly non-stellar at higher magnifications. I estimate that the outer coma subtended approximately 7 arc minutes. To the naked-eye, the comet seemed to be slightly less bright than Algol.

I also observed the comet through a fellow ASH member's 12x36 Canon IS binocular, my 15x70 Burgess Optical binocular, my 80mm f/5 Orion ShortTube 80 achromat at 15 (26mm Tele Vue Ploessl) and 57x (7mm Nagler Type 6), the ASH 4.25" f/4.2 Edmund Scientific Astroscan (28mm Edmund Scientific RKE and 13mm Tele Vue Ploessl), the ASH 5" f/5 achromat finder scope (32mm no name Erfle and 13mm TV Ploessl), a fellow ASH member's 10" f/10 Meade LX200 SCT (36mm Meade QX, 28mm Edmund Scientific RKE, and 26mm Meade QX), and the ASH 14" f/10 Meade LX200GPS SCT (55mm University Optics Ploessl and 36mm Meade QX) during the course of the evening.

The yellow hue that 17P/Holmes is exhibiting was most evident through the 80mm ST80 at 15x. The best overall view was through the 17" at 162x. A brighter view at 118x (55mm University Optics Ploessl) was also quite nice as was the view through the 14" SCT at the two magnifications used.

The image posted at http://www.princeton.edu/~rvdb/images/NJP/17P-Holmes-SumAll.jpg illustrates the comet's motion and is quite similar to what I saw visually through the 17".

This historic cometary outburst is providing absolutely unique views and is yet another of the unexpected events that add spice to observational amateur astronomy.

Dave Mitsky

Chance favors the prepared mind.

De gustibus non est disputandum.
Posted 10/29/2007 02:56PM #1
I've been an amateur astronomer for 50 years and Comet 17P/Holmes is one of the most impressive sights I've seen. I viewed it through my 6" refractor Sunday night using magnification from 50x-250x in the polluted skies of Bergen County N.J. and was amazed. At this time of the year when Jupiter is too low, Mars is small, and Saturns rings are closing this is an unexpected treat. Even my wife was impressed which doesn't happen very often.
Posted 10/29/2007 05:59PM #2
Dave Mitsky said:


17P/Holmes exhibited a distinct inner and outer coma as well as a fan-shaped area of ejecta extending southwestward from the true pseudonucleus, which appeared distinctly non-stellar at higher magnifications. I estimate that the outer coma subtended approximately 7 arc minutes.

On Sunday evening, before moonrise, I had my first look at Comet Holmes in dark sky from my rural NY home using my 20x80 binoculars. I thought that the outer envelope was about a third the size of the moon. After moonrise I had difficulty seeing the outer part in the bright sky. Since Dave liked the view thru a big scope perhaps tonight I'll drag out my Obsession 20.

George N
Posted 10/29/2007 09:08PM #3
Dave,

I was looking at M33 before moonrise, then moved to the obvious new extra "star" in Perseus. Wow! This thing is huge and it's bright, especially after observing galaxies. It was actually a little spooky, too, like an eye looking back at me. I called out my daughters, they ran out in bare feet in the 35 degree weather. My oldest daughter could see that the "star" was a hazy disk with her naked eyes. At 80x and 133x I could see more and more details even though the moon was already up and the sky was quite bright.

Rick

8" Zhumell Dob
90mm f11 achro refractor
4-1/2 f4 rich field newt reflector
Posted 10/30/2007 12:10AM #4
I've been trying to take a look at it through binoculars each night. I was also shocked at how big and bright it was. I also saw it in my 28" scope on Saturday night, just a day or two after full moon. I thought it looked great, but some guests that were over that night (non-astro folks) didn't seem too impressed. I think they were expecting a tail. :S
(but they loved the moon)