Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Standard birding binoculars

Started by light trap, 03/29/2003 08:32PM
Posted 03/29/2003 08:32PM Opening Post
Almost every Sat. morning for the past year, I've been getting together with one of two local NC bird groups for regularly scheduled field trips to locations both local and distant. Now, the interesting thing about these trips is that they attract a very wide range of people of all ages from about 8-80, and from a variety of backgrounds. Rather than being a static crowd of regulars, it's usually comprised of a few of us diehards, and a random selection of people who found out about that week's trip from a variety of sources. We've recently had visitors from Germany, Japan, Taiwan and even Wisconsin. :-) Group size ranges from 2-26, with around a dozen being the norm. But each trip brings new faces, and being curious, I ALWAYS look to see what people are using in terms of optics. When possible, I try to get a look through any that interest me.

To make a long story short, I've seen people bring everything from $20 Tascos to Swarovski ELs and everything in between. That much might be expected. But just as the quality of the optics vary, so do the sizes. The odd thing is that there is no really dominant size. Reading various things about birding optics, one might expect to see a predominance of 8x40 class binoculars. But, really, that's just not the case at all. Sure, the 8x40/42s show up regularly, but they don't dominate the scene or even comprise a majority on any given outing.

Looking just at what 9 fieldtrip leaders and acknowledged experts carry yields the following:
(2) Leica 10x50 BNs roofs
(1) Celestron 8x42 roof
(1) Eagle Optics Ranger 8x32 roof
(1) Canon IS 12x36 (image stabilized)
(2) Swift 8.5x44 Audubon (orig. porros, non-WP)
(1) Leica 8x32 BN roof
(1) Kahles 8x32 roof

The gear of the random, but hardcore birder showing up is even more diverse. Amongst the folks that have logged over 250 species just in NC, I've seen everything from Leica 8x20s to Canon 18x50 IS to Swarovski 7x42 to Nikon Travelites. So what's the birding "standard"? You tell me. I'm totally convinced that binoculars are one of the most individual specific pieces of gear that can be bought. What's right for one, isn't necessarily right for another. So it goes.

Mike Swaim

Posted 03/30/2003 04:28PM #1
I think your last three sentences nicely sum it up. I would never buy a pair of binoculars sight unseen. Anyone considering a binocular purchase should make a big effort to see the models under consideration.

The last time I got a pair sight unseen, which is when my wife wanted to buy me a new pair for my birthday, I was considering the Fujinon 8x40 BFLs and the Bushnell 8x40 Customs (I hope I have the latter right). She got the Fujinons, which I liked just fine. I later ran into someone with a pair of the Bushnells. I tried them, and the focus knob placement was terrible for me. They would have been a big mistake. For my next pair I made sure to personally check out everything on my consideration list. It took a while, and I had to make an effort to see some of them, but it was worth the trouble.
Posted 03/30/2003 05:01PM #2
Some of the more unusal binoculars I've seen in the field would include:

Leica 8x20-- As previously mentioned, these are the SOLE binocular of a hardcore birding enthusiast who's logged over 500 species in the US alone.

Mystery East Euro 6x30 indiv. e.p. focus porros -- The really odd thing about these, aside from being indiv. e.p. focus, was WHO had them. I met an elderly German birder who had a VERY well used set of these as his travel bino. Looking at this gent's clothing, luggage and overall style, it was clear that he could've easily afforded something better, more modern and easier to use. When I asked about them he just chuckled and said that they were "friends" and knew where the birds were. Was that an indirect comment about wide fields and clear optics? I don't know.

Bushnell 10x50 porros -- What makes these an unusal choice is the woman that shows up regularly with these as her only birding glass. For one thing, she wears thick bifocals and uses them with the eyecups extended. I've tried mentioning to her that she'd have a much better view if she'd fold back the eyecups, but she likes them the way she uses them. The other thing about this choice is that when her orig. set developed focuser problems, she actually sent them back to Bushnell. They, in turn, sent her 2 brand new 10x50 binos, so now she & her husband ea. have a set. The final thing that makes this whole rather odd choice worth mentioning is that despite using optics that many of us wouldn't own if they were free, and despite not even using them in a manner that's consistant with getting the most of them, this woman is actually a very good birder. Go figure.

Nikon SE 12x50 porros -- My own choice of gear for most fairweather outings; Oddly, though these are small and light and exceptionally bright in comparison to most 10x50's, and though they rival some 60mm scopes in terms of what they can bring to the eye, I've never seen anybody but myself using these for birding.

Orion 9x63 MGs -- Twice, I've met folks using these in the field. In both cases the users indicated that they got them for am. astro. but found them to be useful for birds and sports as well. I had an older set of these when I 1st got into astro. but quickly sold them when they didn't have the edge performance that I craved.

Pentax 16x60 PCF -- I thought that I might be fairly unusal when I got a set of these for a combo of waterfowling, hawking and backyard astro. Well, I quickly sold them due to a too narrow FOV, but since then, I've seen both 16x60's and mounted 20x60's in use by birders. Recently, there was even a thread about using these binos on a birding email list that I subscribe to. On the Desparately Seeking Binoculars site, expert Ken Rosenberg mentions his fondness for the discontinued WWII era Zeiss 15x50s.

more fuel for the fire...
Mike Swaim


Posted 04/01/2003 05:09AM #3
Clearly it seems that there's no "standard" birding binocular. On my current trip to Honolulu, I'm using three, ranging from a Canon IS 18 x 50, down to Minox BD 10 x 25 BR folding. The latter should be very handy tomorrow, carried on a belt, to certain places in Pearl Harbor, where they frown on any bulky item, but on a day where some of the Hawaiian shorebirds might be an attraction between the ARIZONA and the MISSOURI tours.

And, I think it's very clear that one smaller pair of binoculars that can be taken almost anywhere are always useful, even if your main pair are three times the weight, and six times the price. Birds do NOT not know the difference, any more than a bass can figure out the price tag for the rod that has him hooked, or, the boat on which the angler is standing. (Yes, I'm a catch and release kind of guy....birding is ALWAYS "catch and release"!)

Alan Birnbaum
temporarily on Oahu