Image of the day

Captured by
Craig Bobchin

Coathanger CR 399

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Filter Questions

Started by Boxlock, 08/21/2007 08:07AM
Posted 08/21/2007 08:07AM Opening Post
I just bought an Astronomik filter drawer off A-mart, and now have a question about filters. Given I'm using an older Parallel ST8 (non-E) NAGB, with and 80f/6 refractor, I'll have to guide through the filter, wich will likely make it difficult to find and calibrate on a guide star. I borrowed a Schuller Ha filter from an observing buddy, and screwed it into the nosepiece, just to see if I could do it at all. I chose the elephant trunk as a target, because It had and abundance of great guide stars in the area, and should make an easy target. Here's a median combine of 8 X 20min subs.



Now, I'm wondering....Wich would be better, a filter like the Astrodon wich has a narrower passband, but allows a higher percentage of light at those particular wavelengths through the filter, or a filter like the Astronomik that lets a smaller percentage of light at a particular wavelength through, but has a wider passband allowing more wavelengths to pass, or something in-between the two, like the Schuller?
Posted 08/22/2007 01:56AM #1
Wow! I'm amazed! Does none of the imagers out there have any experience to share, or opinions on this?
Posted 08/22/2007 03:13AM #2
Hi James,

Opinions on filters vary widely, and I'm not well-versed on their capabilities. Experience-wise, I have had fantastic results with my Astrodon H-alpha filter vs. another, narrower-pass-through filter (not sure why, I don't know if I'll get around to running a comparison of the two to find out).

I do have a work-around for you so that guiding through filters is not an issue: get yourself one of those Meade DSI's currently on clearance, find yourself a cheapo guide scope, and just guide externally. Then again, don't you have an EM200? If so, you can probably just bin your guide chip 3x3 and set your guide exposures real long to get at the stars.

I don't know if this is what you're looking for, but it's food for thought.
Eric