Meade DSI II Pro or DSI II Color?

Started by fblue, 09/06/2006 05:59PM
Posted 09/06/2006 05:59PM Opening Post
I know that the Meade DSI is not the premium CCD out there, but if you were to choose between the two, which would it be and why?
DSI II Pro (mono with filters)
DSI II COlor (one shot)

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 09/06/2006 07:23PM #1
Floyd,

Im my humble opinion, the greater sensitivity of the DSI II Pro would offset the inconvenience of needing additional exposures for color shots.

Also, the monochrome camera would let you dabble in narrowband imaging, if that was a future area of interest.

Keith

[COLOR="Navy"]“Heaven wheels above you, displaying to you her eternal glories, and still your eyes are on the ground” --Dante[/COLOR]
Posted 09/07/2006 03:31AM #2
Floyd,
Stuart has a point about the ST237's. But if you go with a Meade, get the Pro. The improved sensitivity will let you pull in better data. Of course, you will be taking more exposures if you want a color image.

Jim Thommes

Mak-Newt 152 mm
C8
Megrez II APO
Zenithstar 66 mm APO
G11/Gemini
ST8300M
Artemis285 Camera
Canon 350D DSLR

http://jthommes.com/Astro/
Posted 09/07/2006 09:34PM #3
If it was me, I would save a little while longer and get an Atik ATK-16: http://www.astrovid.com/prod_details.php?pid=2713 That is a super sensitive camera that takes world class pictures. It is basically an SXV-H9 with a little bit smaller chip. Add an H-Alpha filter and you will be taking world class shots under the worst light pollution. Do a search for that camera and you will see what kind of pictures people are taking with it. It is twice the money that you want to spend, but ten times the camera. You wont take that big a hit either when you decide to sell it to get a bigger chip. Add a cheap APO refractor like an ED80 and an autoguider with a half way decent mount, and you wont run out of things to shoot for a long time. H-Alpha shots are easy to process too. Just stack and stretch. The nice thing about the Atik cameras or the Starlight Express cameras is that you don't have to waste time taking dark frames with them either. The camera is just about noise free. Add a filter wheel later for full color images. Atik makes a pretty nice manual filter wheel too for $200. About the only thing better than that camera is the bigger one. The ATK-16HR, which is the same chip as the SXV-H9.
Ralph
Posted 09/10/2006 08:22PM | Edited 09/10/2006 08:23PM #4
Hi Floyd et al.,

I'm no expert, and I don't mean to hijack your thread, but this discussion is very interesting to me because I have dabbled with my Meade original DSI, but am now reading cool stuff about Stellacam IIs and Mallincams. I, too, am interested in a comparision among these cameras of the "live" image. Anyone's thoughts would be appreciated.

Also, Floyd, have you considered an Orion Starshoot? I thought those were comparable to a Meade DSI, but with thermoelectric cooling?

Mark