Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

slightly OT: STL11000CM an upgrade over a 2000XM?

Started by gregbradley, 04/21/2006 10:51PM
Posted 04/21/2006 10:51PM | Edited 04/21/2006 10:52PM Opening Post
I'd like some opinions from experienced CCD users on whether a STL11000CM is an upgrade over a ST2000XM with a filter wheel.

I notice with some images using a filter wheel you're polar alignment has to be spot on as well as you probably need to refocus with each new filter.
Otherwise you can get rotational effects and bloating effects that reduce the sharpness and resolution of the image. As well as cause some colour artifacts.

Ideally, the images is shot with the same conditions each time. That would mean ideally all colours shot at the same time under the same conditions for that period of exposure. Things rarely duplicate accurately unless a lot fo care is taken (which is OK too but more work and less images will wind up acceptable for use but would ultimately be a higher quality).

I think this is one of the best cases for one shot colour cameras. All colours are shot under the exact same circumstances without minor changes entering in.

For example, you shoot LRG and ready for blue. Cloud comes in! OK. That session is wasted until you can shoot blue another night and spend a fair while aligning before shooting the image. You may also end up compromising on autoguider exposure length to make sure it will be bright enough when the blue filter has its turn.

Comments?

Greg.
Posted 04/22/2006 01:20PM #1
Greg, it depends. I shoot with a ST-2000XM as well. But I shoot with Newtonians. The filters are matched to have the same thickness and refractive indexes. The advantage of the filter wheel is the added selection of filters eg. H-alpha narrow band to bring out the red emissions better. I seen a lot of images on this forum with the H-alpha, OIII, and SII filters stacked onto the LRGB to get enhanced eye candy! And they were done with refractors like your Borg.
Check which filters you got with the camera. The red and green filters in my ST-2000XM do not cross each other possibly to act as a skyglow filter (Custom Scientific). This is true with all of the 1.25 filter sets sold by SBIG. My luminance filter is actually a clear filter that extends into the IR and UV regions. Usually not a problem with reflectors. The Astrodon set does come with a true luminance filter. Check this link to the SBIG filter page.

http://sbig.com/sbwhtmls/online.htm

I seen your test shot of of the LMC with the Tarantula. I noticed there are artifacts in the corners probably due to the polar alignment and/or a clear filter used as a luminance filter on a refractor problem.
We will have to wait till you get a better shot this week without the Moon. Recheck the flat frames as well.
This is a good camera to start cutting teeth with.

There is a remote guide head available for these cameras that usually is attached to an off-axis guider or guide scope to guide without going through the filters.
Due to the inconsistent drive errors in both of my Newtonian mounts, I never used the guide chip, but they are manually guided. I've done 35mm colour film images with my scopes long before switching to CCD camera. The colour emulsions available changed over time according to the whims of the film manufacturers causing colour shifts! The CCD cameras are more consistent in that regard.
Clear skies! Joe.

M27, 18" f4.5 JMI reflector 10, 10, 7, 10 minute LRGB respectively.


Attached Image:

astrophot99's attachment for post 103006