CCD vs Film and resolution?

Started by raw265, 03/12/2003 04:47AM
Posted 03/12/2003 04:47AM Opening Post
I keep hearing this statement from several different sources: "CCD's have a ways to go before they match the resolution of film".

Is this statement accurite? I find it hard to believe with all the CCD pitures that I have seen posted all over the web and here by out resident pro's that this is true. Some of the best shots I have seen have been taken with CCD. The film equivelents don't seem to be close at all. The only thing the film seems to have an edge with is the wide field stuff and even then I've seen some wide field CCD pictures stitched together that have much better contrast, detail and color.


So what gives? Let me know what everyone's opinions are on this matter.


Robert W.

There's no substitute for fine glass!
Posted 03/12/2003 07:12AM #1
Zoom in on those "best shots" ccd images..square stars..
4"x5" or even 6x7 cm film can output 20x24 prints or even 30x40 prints with fine results and hardly a loss in resolution. CCD shots look great on a comp monitor..
Posted 03/12/2003 08:06AM #2
No, actually the exact opposite is true: for some time now, CCD has had much better resoulution than film. The additional resolution of CCD has actually caused a bit of a revolution in mount-building. Losmandy and Mountain INstruments, for example, have had to upgrade the way they make gears to provide tracking accurate enough for CCD imaging. I know because I did the tests on Losmandy-made worm/gear sets that showed this.

Film does have some characteristics that make it a good choice. A large piece of film is cheap; a large CCD chip costs a small fortune. So film still has a big advantage for wide-field imaging, at least if you don't have $25k to spend on a large-chip CCD camera.

From a design standpoint, the usual "pixel size" assigned to film is about 20-25 microns. Most CCD chips in use by amateurs have pixels that are much smaller than this (the ST-10 has 6.8-micron pixels). Some films have an effective "pixel" size that is smaller than 20 microns, but not as small as CCD chips.

(as an aside, you really can't assign a true pixel size to film. Film is made up of grains, each of which is either all black or all white. It takes many grains to make up an image, and there isn't a clear cut "pixel" at all. The numbers I am quoting above are for what we would call an "effective pixel size" - what pixel size CCD chip would have about the same resolution as film?)

Ron Wodaski

Ron Wodaski
New Astronomy Press
http://www.newastro.com
Posted 03/14/2003 12:36AM #3
Well, I want to thank everyone that participated in this somewhat "heated debate". It has confirmed my thoughts that this may have been one of those many "astro myths" (but maybe not until just recently with advances in the latest CCD technology).

Some of the galaxy work I see being done is incredible and I have never seen any film images of this image scale that come close to the detail and contrast. Some of it I think has to do with the long exsposures that are required for film and this has detrimental effects on fine detail.


Again thanks everyone,

Robert W.

There's no substitute for fine glass!