Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

F ratios on DSLR Lenses

Started by Alex McConahay, 11/27/2004 11:18PM
Posted 11/27/2004 11:18PM Opening Post
Here's a question I thought about when looking into buying a DSLR to match my existing collection of Canon EOS lenses.

Okay, I know my existing lenses will fit the new D20. However, I will have to multiply their focal length to get the "equivalent" 35 mm focal length. I.E., my 300 is now a 480 mm lens.

Okay, so what happens to the F ratio?

The aperture has remained the same, the actual focal length of the lens has remained the same, and the angle of the last rays of light coming to the film plane (or chip in this case) has remained the same. So, the F ratio is the same as it is when using a 35mm film camera, right? But what, a third of the light is wasted?

How bright are the finder screens on a 20D compared to an Elan when using the same lens?

The 18-55 zoom they have on the 20D kit--Is it's F3.5 as bright as my 75-300 mm's F 3.5?

Let's have your thoughts.

Alex
Posted 11/28/2004 12:15AM #1
Alex, the f/ratio's remain the same. The actual focal lengths and f/ratios don't change, just the area covered. The brightness per unit area also remains the same, it's just that in the dslr the light isn't being used beyond the sensor area. Therefore, the image brightness at the focus screen "should" be the same. However, as manufacturers moved from the older 35mm slr's to the digital slr's a lot of other design changes took place as well. Some started using penta mirrors rather than penta prisms, and the focusing screens themselves changed somewhat. All this simply means that there is probably no way to make a DIRECT comparison between a dslr and a 35mm slr as far as image brightness is concerned.
I will say that most of the dslr's I have looked through have had good to excellent screen brightness, and at least seemed comparable to the film versions of just a few years ago. I did recently compare my film slr viewfinder (Pentax ZX5n) to a Digital Rebel and a Nikon D70, each with the normal lens. My Pentax was MUCH brighter, but, it has a 50mm f/1.4 normal lens. The other two were f/3.5 at the WA setting, and closer to 4 or 4.5 at the equivalent normal fl setting. BIG difference in the quantity of light hitting the focus screen, and it was apparant. BUT, my Pentax lens is manual focus, the other two cameras were autofocus, and very fast and accurate at that! Personally, I will trade the somewhat dimmer view for the faster and more accurate focus capability any day, especially factoring in my 62 year old eyes smile

Walt