Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mars Image Comparo - C9.25 vs. 6" apo refractor

Started by RLH, 09/22/2005 06:34PM
Posted 09/22/2005 06:34PM Opening Post
I imaged Mars again this morning...only with the Takahashi FS152 6" apo refractor instead of the Celestron C9.25 SCT. This morning was very similar to yesterdays. If there were any difference at all yesterday was very slightly more steady. Even the same side of Mars was captured. This is by no means a scientific comparison. I only did this for fun, out of curiosity, and with hopes to learn a thing or two. One thing that never ceases to amaze me is that the FS152 refractor is much nicer visually and can hold power better, but when it comes to imaging the C9 will maintain crisp images with longer focal lengths over the refractor.

Both scopes were used with a Phillips 840k webcam with a Baader IR blocking filter. The factory Phillips software was used for avi capture @ 20 fps. Registax 2 was used for stacking. Adobe CS was used for processing. I used a Televue 3X barlow with the C9 and for the Tak FS152 I used a TeleVue 4X Powermate and a Denkmeier part S.

I do not wish to start a design/manufacture war, but comments are welcome.

Russell

Attached Image:

RLH's attachment for post 26995

www.flickr.com/photos/61135315@N00/
Posted 09/22/2005 06:55PM #1
Russell,

A nice comparo! I'm not sure the Tak image shows less. In fact, it seems to have greater contrast given the level of processing, and I think a bit more detail can be seen on some parts of the disk.

How about presenting another set with the two images enlarged to the same size, and with contrast levels adjusted to be as similar as possible?

Matt
Glendale, AZ

Posted 09/22/2005 10:57PM #2
Russel,

Very! nice images, it looks like the 6" Tak held up very well to the 9.25 SCT.

Thanks,

Wes Higgins
Posted 09/22/2005 11:01PM #3
It appears that the C9.25 has a bit more detail around the edges of the dark areas.

Too bad you already have a C9.25 - I was going to trade mine to you for the FS152 (as a favor to you, of course).