Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Reciprocity failure and ISO

Started by jsuro, 04/15/2004 10:03PM
Posted 04/15/2004 10:03PM Opening Post
Hi All,

I was at my local photo pro-shop today and they were out of Fuji Provia 400F, which I've been using as of late. I told the owner there that I was pushing the 400F +1 and exposing for over 30 minutes. He proceeded to lecture me on the "fact" that at those long exposures the reciprocity failure curve is such that ISO has little meaning anymore and that I could achieve similar exposure results with Fuji Provia 100F not pushed!

This doesn't sound right to me but is this guy right?

Best,

Jose Suro
Tierra Verde, Florida
Posted 04/15/2004 10:28PM #1
Probably not but it would be an interesting experiment to compare a 30 min exp of each film type of the same object with identical equipment and conditions. I am sure that the differences would be obvious, but I really suspect that other differences would also pop up, such as color balance and resolution and contrast variations between film types. Sometime recently there were some rather nice astrophotos posted here that were taken with 100 speed color neg film, but I can't remember the exposure times.

Walt
Posted 04/15/2004 11:16PM #2
The reciprocity faliure effect is more pronounced with the 400F than it is with 100F. Fuji's datasheets state that with 100F at 4 minutes you loose 1/3 stop and with 400F you loose 1 full stop of sensitivity. It's hard to say if the curve eventually results in the 100F being more sensitive. I would just do at test comparing the two films.

Joplin