Baader solar film D'OH! moment...Posted By Greg Shaffer |
Real astronomers dont read instructions!!! 
Steve Mathis said:
A year ago I bought a sheet of Baader solar film to make a filter for my C11 for visual use. The size of the sheet would allow me to make a 7.5" diameter filter. I debated whether to make a centered opening, a 7.5" with a 3.5" central obstruction, or make a clear 3.5" off-axis filter. I posed the question here on AM as to which would really be the better route, and got little response. So I went for the 7.5"/3.5" CO. The results were horrible: A fuzzy image with all kinds of scattered light in the field. The much touted "black background" these filter should produce was definitely not present. I decided that this "donut" of a filter, a 2" wide strip surrounding the 3.5" CO, was worthless. So I decided to go the other route, and make a new filter mount with the 3.5" off-axis hole. I would cut the filter out of the original mount, and put it in the new one. When I started cutting the filter, this piece of clear plastic started separating from the metalized mylar. I had installed the filter without remove the clear protective cover! D'OH!Needless to say, the optical quality of said clear plastic was pretty poor, and was responsible for the crummy image. The solar image with the new setup is nice and sharp, and yes, the background is nice and black. Of course now I don't know which arrangement would have been better! Maybe when I have an extra $30 I'll start over with the experiment. I'm guessing there was something in the instructions that mentioned removing the clear plastic...