Nagler 22 versus Nagler 20Posted By K. Michael Malolepszy |
See
http://members.leapmail.net/~ericj/equipment_reviews2.html#1
I'd have to agree with the comments comparing the Nagler T5 20 & T4 22 at the above link.
I have both and use the 20 more - even though it has less eye relief - something I don't mind. In fact, I like it - forcing my eye closer to the eye cup seems to reduce light reflections coming from the eye lense side. Another reason I use it more is because of it's light weight compared to the 22 - makes balancing my 11" dob much easier. I also like the idea of fewer elements in the light path (6 vs 7), which may increases contrast a tad - though I suspect reports of the 20 being more contrasty than the 22 has to do with the eye's closer placement to the eye lense and reducing stray light from entering that side of the eyepiece.
http://members.leapmail.net/~ericj/equipment_reviews2.html#1
I'd have to agree with the comments comparing the Nagler T5 20 & T4 22 at the above link.
I have both and use the 20 more - even though it has less eye relief - something I don't mind. In fact, I like it - forcing my eye closer to the eye cup seems to reduce light reflections coming from the eye lense side. Another reason I use it more is because of it's light weight compared to the 22 - makes balancing my 11" dob much easier. I also like the idea of fewer elements in the light path (6 vs 7), which may increases contrast a tad - though I suspect reports of the 20 being more contrasty than the 22 has to do with the eye's closer placement to the eye lense and reducing stray light from entering that side of the eyepiece.
sebrin campbell said:
I'm interested in the choice between the TeleVue Nagler 22mm type 4 versus the TeleVue Nagler 20mm type 5.
I'll probably be using one of these eyepieces in my Tak Mewlon 300 (f/11.9) to fill the gap between a Nagler 31 and a Nagler 16 type 5.
The 'instadjust' eye guard of the 22 is not an issue for me, since I've used, and appreciate that feature on TeleVue Radian eyepieces.
I may not have the opportunity to field test either eyepiece before buying, so I would like to consider all opinions about either eyepiece in trying to make a choice.
Thanks
PS: I don't wear eyeglasses for observing.