C5 vs. C102 vs. F5 6inch NewtPosted By David Keller |
There are a few conditions that could be mucking-up the works here:
1. Perpetually bad seeing conditions. Where do you live?
2. Has the scope cooled down adequately or is the i.d. of the tube too narrow such that there are perpetual tube currents?
3. How do you collimate the scope? Sight Tube + Cheshire + Star Test? Laser + Star Test? Don't finish off with Star Test?
4. At best collimation so far, do you get a good diffraction pattern that is relatively equal in intensity on both sides of focus at high power with no signs of other abberations?
5. The primary mirror could be crappy. If collimation is good, the Star Test will easily detect this but seeing conditions typically need to be good.
Without knowing who the manufacturer of the scope is, I'm going to guess that the problem is either bad seeing, crappy primary mirror, or combination of the two.
A 6" f/5 Newt with good optics, good collimation, and good seeing conditions will give excellent views of the planets.
In my opinion, a C-5 or 4" Achromat cannot match a 6" f/5 Newt when everything is in good operating condition and the atmosphere is reasonably stable.
See if you can get the primary mirror evaluated. If the scope is a budget, mass produced item, there is a good chance that the mirror could be of poor quality. It's not easy to produce a good fast mirror at commodity prices.
Dave Keller
1. Perpetually bad seeing conditions. Where do you live?
2. Has the scope cooled down adequately or is the i.d. of the tube too narrow such that there are perpetual tube currents?
3. How do you collimate the scope? Sight Tube + Cheshire + Star Test? Laser + Star Test? Don't finish off with Star Test?
4. At best collimation so far, do you get a good diffraction pattern that is relatively equal in intensity on both sides of focus at high power with no signs of other abberations?
5. The primary mirror could be crappy. If collimation is good, the Star Test will easily detect this but seeing conditions typically need to be good.
Without knowing who the manufacturer of the scope is, I'm going to guess that the problem is either bad seeing, crappy primary mirror, or combination of the two.
A 6" f/5 Newt with good optics, good collimation, and good seeing conditions will give excellent views of the planets.
In my opinion, a C-5 or 4" Achromat cannot match a 6" f/5 Newt when everything is in good operating condition and the atmosphere is reasonably stable.
See if you can get the primary mirror evaluated. If the scope is a budget, mass produced item, there is a good chance that the mirror could be of poor quality. It's not easy to produce a good fast mirror at commodity prices.
Dave Keller